Tag: ai

  • A glossary for AI cultists vs. us


    The subhed on that Politico story above gets the election right in crediting “safety hawks, populists, and child-safety advocates” who united to oppose AI companies and their data centers in the midterms. But Politico got the main headline terribly wrong. These are not “AI doomers.” AI doomers are the AI cultists who, paradoxically and illogically, claim their own technology could doom humankind — and that’s why they should be given unfettered control over it.

    The doomers are the bad guys. But Politico’s headline said the bad guys won because that’s how these bad guys skew the language around AI and corrupt discourse about it. The result is that the top AI technologists and investors talk at 180-degree cross-purposes to media, policymakers, and the public. When they say “safety” it’s not how the rest of us define “safety.” Same for “regulation,” “humanity,” “doom,” even “future.”

    Their intent is to confuse public discourse, and it works, making us think that when we say “safety” we’re discussing the same idea. We’re not — witness that Politico headline and too much credulous media coverage of AI.

    So it is time to provide a helpful glossary contrasting the AI boys’ language with ours.

    Future vs. “future”

    What we mean: Next month, next year, next election, maybe next generation — time reasonably understood to be under our influence.

    What the AI cultists mean: Their faux philosophers are no slouches. They work at Oxford — or worked; one of them, Nick Bostrom, was ousted with his Future of Humanity Institute when racist emails in his past were exposed. His fellow traveler, William MacAskill, wrote What We Owe the Future, published by Hachette, a textbook for the ideology they call Longtermism: that the future that matters is whatever affects the 10-to-the-54th future human beings yet to come. Their implication is that what bedevils us in the present — whether injustice or inequity, plague or Holocaust — pales in comparison to anything that would hinder the happiness of all those future beings.

    These technocrats are utilitarians who contend they can calculate and affect total happiness. That is what leads to such noxious thinking as this from one of their number: Here, a New York Times profile of Anthropic cofounder Dario Amodei perfectly illustrates the poison fruit of Utilitarianism.

    In a blog post for GiveWell that year, Dr. Amodei discussed a decision to give away $10,000. He was choosing to donate to either the Stop TB Partnership, which focused on preventing adult tuberculosis, or VillageReach, which helped vaccinate children in African villages.

    The Stop TB Partnership, Dr. Amodei wrote, was superior in “cost-effectiveness” because it served adults and “adults are capable of deeper and more meaningful experiences” than infants. “I think an adult death is perhaps 2 or 3 times worse than an infant’s death,” he added.

    He thinks he can judge which humans are more valuable. That is the bridge that connects Utilitarianism and Longtermism to eugenics: the making of the Übermensch.

    Human vs. “human”

    What we mean: Us.

    What the AI cultists mean: They mix the tenets of technology and philosophy, claiming they can use computers to build better humans — that indeed, human and machine will merge and become one in what they call the singularity. That is their doctrine of Singulatarianism.

    Their quest begins with the chips that cultist extraordinaire Elon Musk wants to implant in heads, leads next to the humanoid robots Musk plans to sell (instead of his punchline-on-wheels, the Cybertruck), and ends with the belief that human psyche can be uploaded to machines and live forever and everywhere.

    That encapsulates their belief in Extroprianism: that the mind can transcend the limits of the body. It also speaks to their version of a philosophy called Rationalism: when future humans think not like the base animals we are but instead rationally, like, well, algorithms. When the AI boys build what they call neural networks, some think they are building brains.

    And that is how Bostrom gets to his magic number of 10-with-54-zeroes future human beings. They’re not like us. They’re not us. They are humans as machines, machines as humans, better than us: Übermaschinen.

    Environment vs. “environment”

    What we mean: Our dear Earth.

    What the AI cultists mean: The universe, which they contend they can and will colonize with their human/machines. That is why Musk obsesses about Mars. This is called Cosmism.

    Altruism vs “altruism:

    What we mean: Unselfishly thinking and generously acting on behalf of others’ needs.

    What the AI cultists mean: You’ve no doubt heard of “effective altruism” (EA), another of the AI cultists’ philosophies. This one was made infamous by Sam Bankman-Fried, convicted crypto fraudster and proponent of EA.

    In the beginning, EA sounded reasonable enough, motivating the well-to-do to focus their charitable generosity on acts that will cause the most good. The example always used is buying mosquito nets to save lives. Who can nitpick that?

    Ah, but when you follow this Utilitarian string — maximizing good — to its extreme, mixing in other of these zealous philosophies along the way, you throw out the mosquito nets and the African children saved by them in favor of investments that will benefit Bostrom’s Übermenschen: technologies like superintelligent AI. These effective altruists believe they know best how to invest society’s wealth and so they should have more of it. These altruists aren’t so altruistic after all; they are greedy money-grubbers and this is their wealth gospel.

    Doom vs. “doom”

    What we mean: ’Bye, all.

    What the AI cultists mean: Their machines will become so intelligent, so powerful, so uncontrollable that they can destroy humankind. This is the thesis of Bostrom’s famous paperclip scenario, in which machines told to make nothing but paperclips will turn every resource on earth into paperclips, never mind humans’ needs for energy and oxygen: Clippy’s revenge.

    There’s another variant on Doomerism from its primary prophet, Eliezer Yudkowsky, coauthor of the Doom bible, If Anyone Builds It, Everyone Dies: Why Superhuman AI would Kill Us All (also cynically published by Hachette). Cheery fellow. He loves the idea of superhuman AI but fears that if it is built badly and backfires, it could destroy humankind before it serves Bostrom’s future beings. Thus Yudkowsky says all AI should be stopped until we’re ready, else it should be destroyed with thermonuclear weapons so the remaining humans can learn their lesson and pick up work when they’re ready. This he calls safety.

    Safety vs. “safety”

    What we mean: Since the seminal Stochastic Parrots paper in 2021, AI safety has been clearly defined, focusing on harm to the environment (resources and climate), economy (labor and cost), public discourse (bias and disinformation). It is not complicated; so clear AI can grok it. I asked AI (Gemini) to summarize the paper’s definition [its emphasis]: “For the authors, ‘AI safety’ is not about preventing an autonomous AI takeover; it is about preventing real-world harm to human beings — especially marginalized populations — caused by irresponsible data practices, resource consumption, and the uncritical deployment of large-scale statistical models.” Right.

    What the AI cultists mean: If we take all the related isms I’ve mentioned thus far — Transhumanism, Extroprianism, Singulatarianism, Cosmism, Rationalism, Effective Altruism, Longtermism — and put them together, it spells TESCREAL, an acronym coined by Stochastic Parrots coauthor Timnit Gebru with Émile Torres. Here is their paper that explains these faux philosophies and their roots in eugenics.

    And that is what makes up the foundation of the AI cultists’ definition of safety: managing the all-powerful AI they are building so it does not, one way or another, destroy humankind. Safety to them has nothing to do with environmental damage, childhood safety, or disinformation. It’s all about doom.

    This bit of dictionary disarray comes home to roost in media coverage of AI “safety,” as when The New York Times reports on a gathering hosted by the Future of Life Institute (FLI) that attracted odd bedfellows Bernie Sanders and Steve Bannon — without once mentioning that FLI is funded by known doomers and that “safety” went undefined. Through such coverage, the doomers — AI boys of one stripe or another — gain legitimacy.

    The same problem arises when some employee leaves an AI company to supposedly blow the whistle on a lack of attention to safety there. We think they mean safety in our definition and reporters never ask them to define it. If they bothered, they’d find that often these departees are doomers.

    Media and policymakers are blind to the cultists’ dangerous nuttiness because they successfully hide behind virtuous words — safety, altruism, and regulation — whose meanings they have hijacked and mangled.

    Regulation vs. “regulation”

    What we mean: Government intervention in an industry or activity to ensure a mandated level of transparency and accountability to the public good.

    See, for example, Mallory McMorrow’s proposal to regulate AI, calling for transparency and testing, export controls, and humans in charge. We can and should debate the particulars, but that is a sane starting point.

    What the AI cultists mean: The so-called frontier AI companies — Anthropic and OpenAI — say they favor regulation. But in their plan, this means they write the regulations to favor themselves and exclude start-up and open-source (open-weight) competitors. This is classic regulatory capture.

    They also tout their self-regulation, with Anthropic putting forth its “constitution” for AI, asserting that they can make machines (which can’t count the Rs in “strawberry”) operate according to high principles. OpenAI has proposed frankly naive plans for world bodies to oversee AI.

    Some AI boys, led by VC Marc Andreessen, are accelerationists. They believe any regulation hindering the progress of AI is evil. As Andreessen wrote in his breathless techno-optimist manifesto: “Technology is the glory of human ambition and achievement, the spearhead of progress, and the realization of our potential…. We can advance to a far superior way of living, and of being…. We believe intelligence is the ultimate engine of progress. Intelligence makes everything better…. We believe Artificial Intelligence is our alchemy, our Philosopher’s Stone — we are literally making sand think.”

    The serious problem with all the definitional disconnects I’ve outlined here is that without agreement on what harm is to be mitigated, it is impossible to hold a meaningful debate over how to regulate it, how to hold its makers and users accountable while sharing the fruits of this impressive technology.

    Intelligence vs. “intelligence”

    What we mean: Don’t know. That is why the first book I commissioned for the Bloomsbury series I am editing, Intelligence: AI & Humanity, is by Dr. Rumman Chowdhury, who will examine this human construct in the context of history, where it has been used to exclude and has inspired a mania to measure what remains an abstract concept. To my mind, intelligence is that which defines humanity.

    What the AI cultists mean: They think it is easy not only to define intelligence but to build it and set benchmarks for it. Not just that, they think they can build machines that will beat human intelligence by any measure. They call this Artificial General Intelligence (AGI)— general in the sense that it can do anything we can do — or Artificial Superintelligence (ASI) — super in the sense that it can do all that better than we can. The frontier companies headed for their trillion-dollar IPOs say they’re nearly there, that their generative AI chat machines will soon be so damned smart they can build and improve on themselves.

    OpenAI’s Sam Altman and others in the field treat intelligence as a commodity their companies can make, own, and sell, as if from a vending machine. That is their utmost dehumanization of us all.


    There are AI people who are not in the cult, thank goodness. One I admire is Yann LeCun, who believes that language-based generative models will take development of AI only so far. He favors real-world models that learn the laws of physics and are built for and limited to specific, controllable functions, rather than becoming the everything machine. He also is an advocate of open-source, open-weight AI to spur competition and innovation. Another proponent of world models is Fei-Fei Li.

    I wish scientists and contrarian builders like LeCun would get more attention in media coverage of AI. I wish scholars like Gebru would be called upon to give audiences context on the outlandish claims of the AI boys. I wish journalists would press those AI boys on definitions inherent in those claims. I wish they would stop allowing the boys to anthropomorphize their machines — as if they have motives and morals — and stop doing so themselves. And when writing about AI, I wish they would discard the AI boys’ dictionary in favor of Webster’s.

    This American election was indeed a repudiation of AI and its data centers. But I say data centers are merely the McGuffins of the drama — that is, tangible symbols of the actual objects of dislike and distrust: the AI oligarchs and billionaires who wield their wealth in our elections, who threaten to destroy humankind (and demand the power to do so), who are generally jerks, and who maim the language to obfuscate their own intent.

    I think AI is an amazing and promising technology whose opportunities we have just begun to explore. I cohost two podcasts about AI (Intelligent Machines and AI Inside) and, as I said, I’m editing a book series to bring the humanities into the discussion about it. But I say the wrong people are in charge of this technology, and those people are conning the journalists and politicians who should see through them to stop them from ruining it for us all. Start with clear language.

    As I finished writing this, I returned to Politico and found that the editors (or A/B testing or AI) thought better of the headline above. This is how a later version read:

  • They’re covering the wrong AI story

    At least one New York Times journalist — columnist Michelle Goldberg — has at last begun covering the real AI story: not the technology but the technologists and their cult of faux philosophies that lead them to claim Promethean powers to destroy humanity. With their self-fulfilling prophesies of extinction, the AI boys grab the attention of unwary media and policymakers while distracting from the real costs and dangers — and benefits — of the machines they make.

    The calls of doom have been coming from inside the AI house, though Goldberg notes that coverage of them — which I will critique here — is “incomplete, because it doesn’t account for tech leaders’ messianic dreams.” In recent columns, another Times columnist, Georgetown computer science Professor Cal Newport, has begun to explore the AI boys’ insane philosophies. “This exaggerated grimness,” Newport writes, “makes it easy to overlook the more immediate harms created by these technologies…. The time has come to push back.” He says their nihilistic doom trolling has to stop.

    That’s a start. I wish their coverage would go deeper by citing the work of Timnit Gebru and Émile Torres, who catalog the AI cult’s full range of creeds under the acronym TESCREAL — for Transhumanism, Extroprianism, Singularitarianism, Cosmism, Rationalism, Effective Altruism, and Longtermism. Nevermind the specific doctrines. What is worthy of your — and media’s and policymakers’ — attention is that Gebru and Torres show how all these beliefs have their roots in eugenics.

    Goldberg does note that some of their plutocratic adherents quote fascists and Nietzsche. Their goal is to select Übermenschen as they play God, building mythical, supposedly conscious “artificial general intelligence” and “superintelligence;” transforming themselves into man-machines with chips in their heads; using AI to help them live forever; populating Mars and the universe beyond with their progeny; and claiming responsibility for the future, never mind today’s trivial concerns. These überwealthy zealots have the resources — technology, capital, celebrity— and access to power to pursue their fevered, fascist dreams. 

    That is scary shit. But that’s not the scary shit we see covered in news media.

    Instead, news media lap up the AI overlords’ claims of suprahuman power. Right across The Times’ home page from Goldberg and Newport, editors regurgitate whole the doomsters’ pronouncements without bothering with basic reporting, finding other authorities who disagree. Where is bothsidesing when we need it?

    Next, The Times gives unchallenged top-of-homepage prominence to Anthropic CEO Dario Amodei’s call to slow down AI development. 

    What’s wrong with that? you ask. Much, I say. 

    • First, journalists unquestioningly accept as gospel the doomers’ assertions that their creations are capable of such danger, while there are many who believe these claims are just a perverse form of macho marketing meant to demonstrate to investors how very powerful and valuable they are. 
    • Second, this is classic regulatory capture: The “frontier” AI companies call for regulations that they will help lawmakers draft, which will raise the bar for entry into their market for the open and international startup competition we so badly need to challenge them. 
    • Third, the doom scenarios seduce click-hungry media into giving them free publicity and that lures equally dupable politicians — Bernie Sanders and Ted Lieu leading the pack — to call for simplistic, instant solutions: namely unplug AI. Meanwhile, vestigial pro-business Republicans wait for Trump’s inscrutable instructions. See how The Times practically scolds pols for not panicking enough:

    Out of all this arm-waving, either nothing will happen or Anthropic and OpenAI will succeed in blocking new competitors while getting ultrawealthy on their IPOs. And few pay attention to the real perils these technologies raise for the environment, labor, education, and culture. 

    There’s another critical risk: that we all lose the opportunity to develop and put to use these promising, often impressive technologies in medicine, science, carefully considered educational applications, and daily life. Such is always the peril of moral panic. 

    I am not an AI doomer, as you will surmise. Neither am I an AI accelerationist: “Damn the torpedoes, warp speed ahead.” Having studied the history of technologies related to media in my books, I recognize lessons from the past: that disruptive technologies, especially those related to speech, induce panic at first; that before long the public comes to harness new technologies; that the technologists and their power eventually fade into the background; and that, with fits and missteps, society figures out how to make good use of its machines. We did it with movable type, steam, electricity, and electronics, and I believe we’ll get there with the internet. We can figure out AI, too. 

    AI in its many flavors — large language models are just one limited instance — are proving to be amazing. In some areas — analysis of proteins, possibly theoretical math, perhaps medicine discovery, and certainly coding — they are surpassing human ability. But that by no means is any indication of either general or super intelligence. To me, AGI is just another abbreviation for BS. I hold that artificial general intelligence is a wasteful goal fueled by the hubris of the AI boys. As the sane AI pioneer Yann LeCun instructs, machines programmed and trained to perform specific tasks will be faster and cheaper to build — and control — than some fabled, all-powerful überbrain of Oz.

    I believe we should understand what these technologies can and cannot do and cover them accordingly. That is why I cohost two podcasts — AI Inside and Intelligent Machines — to keep up on the news. This is also why I am editing a series for Bloomsbury Academic — Intelligence: AI & Humanity — to invite scholars and writers from the humanities and social sciences to this critical conversation, for they are not heard enough.

    Our first book in the series will be by Rumman Chowdhury, an expert in AI ethics and governance. She will examine our definitions of intelligence over time. What fascinates me about AI’s entry into public discourse and culture is that its presence forces us to reexamine our own ideas of intelligence, creativity, art, learning, trust, labor, the firm, and even — in the case of the AI cultists who claim deific powers — religion. (See this relevant interview with Inken Prohl in Die Zeit: “With AI, we have created a religion.”)

    Coverage of AI in mainstream media is consistently appalling. It too often accepts the PR of the AI boys — whether utopian or dystopian, accelerationist or doomster — without challenge, skepticism, or balance. When the AI boys talk about “AI safety,” journalists rarely exhibit the sophistication to ask whether that is safety in the common sense (environmental, educational, cultural) or in the AI cultists’ overblown sense (doom and extinction). 

    When we hear of episodes of supposed AI agent “swarms” going “rogue” and “hacking” into systems, journalists use scare words to pump up the drama by attributing malign motives to overgrown calculators. Worse, they give us incomplete reporting. They should be asking what the AI companies fail to tell us. In the case of the OpenAI/Hugging Face incident, we need to know what the company told its model to do before we can decide whether it disobeyed those instructions. We also deserve to know how OpenAI let its system go unmonitored for so long. Instead of just accepting the AI CEOs’ versions of the story, we need to demand greater transparency, and that will come only through tougher reporting. 

    Media’s anthropomorphism badly clouds the discussion. Let’s be very clear: AI does not think. It calculates. AI is not conscious or sentient. AI has no sense of meaning. It has no motive and no sense of right or wrong, thus it is not lying or cheating. If it breaks laws or norms, we likely should hold responsible those who programmed or instructed it. 

    We need journalists to do more rigorous and skeptical reporting, to study lessons from the history of technology, and to seek out scholars and experts rather than just taking the word of AI’s CEOs, VCs, and disaffected nerds. The end result is that policymakers and the public are ill-equipped to both use and judge these technologies. 

    And we are using them. According to the Pew Research Center, more than half of Americans aged 18–49 say they interact with AI at least once a day — even as they express growing unease unto antipathy toward the technology and the data centers it runs on. The South Korean government will provide AI access to all citizens for free: universal AI as a right. Artificial intelligence is here to stay; there is no turning it off. We deserve the right to have a voice in how AI is developed, governed, and used. 

    To do that, we require well-informed journalism. This is not that:

    That story offers no credible scenario of extinction. It cites the fabled paper-clip hypothesis of the former Oxford philosopher of Effective Altruism, Nick Bostrom, who contended that a machine told to do nothing but make paper clips could monomaniacally make paper clips of us all. Oxford shut down Bostrom’s Elon-Musk-backed Future of Humanity Institute when old email of his was revealed to have said “Blacks are more stupid than whites” and used the N-word. This is why when discussing the doomster beliefs of AI cultists, the context of eugenics matters. But no mention of that by The Journal

    In that article, while fueling the “freakout” it purports to report on, The Journal waits until ten paragraphs in before labeling extinction prognostication a “fringe opinon.” At least it does that. 

    In this, The Times accepts AI companies’ excuses for why they can’t stop their AI from going rogue, while at the same time accepting their assertions that they can create AI that is “aligned” with human values.

    Well, if you want to worry, here’s the real troubling news: This idea of AI alignment — of guardrails to prevent bad outcomes — is ultimately a fool’s errand, for there is no way for any AI company to predict and prevent every possible malign or accidentally harmful use of AI. That is the reality we need to be discussing. 

    Instead, in that headline, The Washington Post anoints Dario Amodei, Sam Altman, and — gulp — Elon Musk as our “top AI leaders.” No, these are the profoundly self-interested CEOs of three companies selling AI, who are given free space to promote their own agendas without proper context. They share one interest: to pull the ladder up after them and make it more difficult for competition — especially Chinese AI companies and more importantly free and open models — to challenge them. Here, The Post is acting as their agent. 

    Can AI be dangerous? Of course, it can. AI has been used by Russia to guide autonomous drones to kill Ukrainians. Perhaps our greatest fear is that AI could be used to craft bioweapons. But The Times concedes that even with instructions, it’s tough to actually make them. 

    The more frightening truth — one that should be on our minds after this anniversary — is that in the wrong hands, any technology can be used as a weapon … even passenger jetliners. We have met the problem, and it is us. 

    I do see the need for wise policy around AI, including:

    • Demand for full transparency from AI companies. Congress would do well to sic expert staffers (not grandstanding pols) on the AI companies to dig into programmers’ and executives’ negligent behavior in cases such as the OpenAI/Hugging Face incident.
    • Support for open-weight models (the closest AI gets to open-source) to provide competition to OpenAI, Anthropic, and SpaceX. These frontier companies want to frighten policymakers into banning these upstarts, especially those from China. Do not fall for it. 
    • Support for fundamental, frontier AI research in universities to provide more competition to the IPO-mad frontier companies and to have this work done under the ethical, open, and peer-reviewed standards of the academy. We could also use a modern-day Bell Labs with a public mission to do AI research. 
    • Support study of AI and its impact and implications by scholars in the humanities and social sciences. 

    Are there alternatives sources for good coverage of AI? Not many. Here are a few: If you want to dig down into the rathole of the AI boys’ philosophies, there is no better place to start than Gebru and Torres’ TESCREAL work. If you want to follow the big, big money behind this movement and what it is building on college campuses and many acronymed institutes, follow the investigations of researcher Nirit Weiss-Blatt. And for clear — though not simple — explanations of the recent scares over AI, I recommend Newport’s latest podcast, particularly this episode and this. 

    Perhaps journalism’s greatest folly is that it treats the self-serving heads of companies that make AI as experts and even intellectuals, though many of them left college early, which is why their frequent manifestos sound like the work of freeze-dried sophomores. News media need to seek out the expertise of historians, ethicists, anthropologists, sociologists, philosophers, legal scholars, economists, and community leaders to help inform all of us about the opportunities and risks of the age we are entering. 

  • Words matter. Damnit.

    On this week’s Intelligent Machines, we cohosts had a spirited disagreement about Anthropic’s watermarking of text, as required by EU regulation. The company just released more detail about how it will work, and now I’m upset for a different reason than I first thought.

    I’m angry as a writer.

    Anthropic’s method will alter its models’ word choices in a pattern based on a key only it knows, allowing it to detect writing (or editing or translation) by its machine — to an uncertain degree of certainty. The company contends there is no difference in meaning between the otherwise random choices “grey” or “overcast” in, for example, the context of weather. So what’s the issue?

    Thus Anthropic declares words fungible, language random, choice meaningless. Not to me. I try to select my words as carefully as I can for a number of considerations: style, tone, rhythm, avoiding repetition, but most of all meaning. You may quibble with my choices, but they are mine, not yours; that’s what makes my writing mine, to communicate what I wish to communicate. “Gray” and “overcast” are not the same, damnit. That’s the reason we have both of them.

    So I resent Anthropic et al dismissing the value of a writer’s selection of one word over another for the impact that decision has on expression, on impression — occasionally on art.

    We humans might not be able to detect whether the machine or the key is being used. That’s not the point. The selections/changes/alterations made in accordance with the key will affect sense and style on an ever-larger proportion of text entering discourse, and the fact that Anthropic (and the EU) consider this acceptable, unimportant, even trivial has cultural impact on the worth of words. They devalue writing. At the very moment when LLMs commodify writing and writers, this is just another kick to the kidneys for a challenged craft.

    And why is this forensic breadcrumb trail being required? Because of prejudice against the technology: fear unto moral panic. But technological solutions to perceived technological problems have just as many unintended consequences as the problems themselves, often more. The irony is that in a zealous effort to protect the distinctiveness — the sanctity — of human text, the authorities and the technologists deprecate what makes text human.

    In my new book Hot Type, I quote critics such as Friedrich Kittler insisting that typewriters changed how Nietzsche, Hemingway, or Hesse wrote and thought. At the end my book, in what I call a typographical autobiography, I recount how technologies, from typewriter to computer to PostScript, affected my composition and cognition. These technologies affected my methods, but that makes my prose no less human. We should debate what the impact of this next technology, AI, might be on creativity and perception, but we should give that process time. Rushing to regulatory and technological solutions to a problem not yet fully understood is foolish.

    So I’m pissed.

    Here is a sentence from the first page of Hot Type, one I chipped away at innumerable times. These are the choices I made:

    Unlike what we now call machines — computer chips veiled inside sleek and sealed grey boxes with no moving parts, save fans to cool their brains— the Linotype’s innards were left exposed, as if to show off the genius of its works: its troop of idiosyncratically shaped cams, gears, belts, arms, and wheels marching to instructions foreseen more than a century before by their inventor, German-born watchmaker Ottmar Mergenthaler.

    Now let us recast it with perfectly acceptable synonyms, as Anthropic’s detection key might, in composition, editing, or translation. In fact, I asked Claude to do just that. Here is what it delivered as “a synonym-substituted version, keeping the structure and meaning intact.”

    Contrary to what we presently term machines — microprocessors concealed within polished and enclosed grey containers with no moving components, except fans to cool their circuitry — the Linotype’s mechanisms were left visible, as if to display the ingenuity of its craftsmanship: its brigade of distinctively shaped cams, gears, belts, arms, and wheels progressing to directives anticipated more than a century earlier by their creator, German-born horologist Ottmar Mergenthaler.

    You may find Claude’s just fine. I find that it misses the wonder, cadence, and anachronism I tried to convey. Anthropic’s engineers and the EU’s regulators may ask, what’s the prob? Much, I say.

  • AI Communism

    In response to the spectre of Chinese open-weight AI models haunting America, Dean Ball, OpenAI’s director of strategic futures [are there directors of strategic pasts?], issued a warning more shrill even than the New York Post’s alerts about Mamdani’s bus-and-grocery socialism. 

    One probable outcome of an open-weight-model-dominant world is full AI communism, which is precisely what China proposes: rather than a market product, AI is a “public good” which will ultimately be provided by the state as a kind of “digital public infrastructure.” This future strikes me as a dystopian hellscape, but I’ve never met an open-weight models advocate who doesn’t ultimately concede this is where things end.

    As Jason Howell and I discussed this on our podcast, AI Inside, we found ourselves asking, What would be so wrong with AI communism? What if there were AI for all? Eh, comrades?

    Imagine all that could be created, often for free, on top of open AI models: how many universities and researchers, startups and entrepreneurs, artists and students could better afford the technology. Imagine the greater control that comes from locally hosted models. Imagine the greater transparency and security that comes with openness. And imagine the power — pricing and political — that could be wrested from the new AI giants as they barrel toward their IPOs…which, of course, is precisely what frightens them. But you need not imagine all this, for open-weight models are affording these opportunities now. 

    By championing open AI, we could atone for past sins (including mine) of insufficiently supporting openness in the first phase of the internet, leading to the fencing of the commons. Open AI may be our best and only defense against its oligarchic domination. As the wise John Palfrey, head of the MacArthur Foundation, just said, “This is a design moment — for the technologies, for the way we relate to one another across geographic and political boundaries, and for what the future looks like.”

    A week after Ball’s cri de code, Nvidia founder and CEO Jensen Huang posted an open letter supporting open-weight models, now signed (as I write this) by fifty AI giants — pretty much everybody who matters … except Anthropic. Even Ball’s bosses signed. It is a remarkable endorsement of open computing and a message to governments. I recommend reading it in full:

    The Washington Post puzzled over why Nvidia et al would “take a stand that helps their Chinese rivals.” (Note that Post owner Bezos’ Amazon has not signed this letter.)

    But of course, open-weight AI is in the business interests of Nvidia and AI chip companies: the more AI is used, the more chips are needed. Locally run, open AI is also in the interests of countless companies. I hate to find myself agreeing with Palantir’s Alex Karp, but he tells his corporate clients they should run open-weight, locally hosted models so they don’t give over the souls of their business to the frontier AI companies; this is his business model.

    Openness is also in the interests of an enlightened AI industry, as it creates competition and that yields greater innovation. This is why an AI pioneer I greatly respect, Yann LeCun, doggedly supports open-source AI and why he founded Project Tapestry, “a new open-source platform for globally federated development of frontier AI models — preserving local control and long-term independence.”

    Now just as sanity was emerging in the discussion about AI, moral panic reared its sweaty head again when credulous media reported that an OpenAI model had gone rogue and “hacked” into Hugging Face. This turns out to be another instance of the doom-as-marketing strategy engaged in by both OpenAI and Anthropic. It is their way to attract publicity and venture funding and control the conversation about regulation of AI. In truth, OpenAI’s model was engaged in a security test; it only did was it was instructed; it has no sense of right or wrong or “hacking;” it isn’t a rogue threat to society, no matter how much the AI boys would like to believe they hold such power.

    The chef’s-kiss irony of the Hugging Face affair was that the platform found American models useless in its defense against the “hack” because they were all hampered by guardrails forbidding them from undertaking tasks regarding security risks. Hugging Face had to rely instead on an open-weight Chinese model.

    Such panics, predictably, lead to threats of government control of AI, and that worries the hell out of me, especially and obviously given the IQ of the current administration. In Congress, Reps. Ted Lieu (D-California) and Nathaniel Moran (R-Texas) have proposed the AI Kill Switch Act, which would require major AI companies to install the means for their models to be shut off in the event of a “credible risk.” And who will have the power to decide to pull the plug? The secretary of Homeland Security.

    No, no no. 

    When I attended a World Economic Forum (Davos) AI event in San Francisco sometime ago, one faction of worrywarts urged the banning of open-weight, open-source AI because users could turn off guardrails, and then who knows what chaos would ensue. But as I often argue, guardrails are fools’ comfort, for there is no way for any model maker to anticipate and thus prevent every possible malign or accidentally harmful use to which their tools could be put. That doesn’t mean that AI companies should not be expected to try to prevent against known malicious or dangerous acts. But AI is a general machine, like the printing press. There was no way to tell Gutenberg to design his movable type such that no future Martin Luther could ever make mischief with it.

    Open-weight models are our best defense against hegemonic control of the technology by either governments or huge AI corporations. They are also the best way to put AI into the hands of more people, not just those who can afford to spend fortunes on hosted tokens. That throws a wrench into Sam Altman’s plans to sell back to us our collective intelligence as if it were a commodity. “We see a feature where intelligence is a utility, like electricity or water,” Altman says, “and people buy it from us on a meter.” Thereby, Altman concedes that AI is, if not a public good at least a public utility. 

    Now I will object to the idea that what AI offers is “intelligence.” That is a gross anthropomorphism that, by its very conception, competes with and excludes humanity. But for the sake of this discussion, for the moment, let’s use it.

    If intelligence is an asset that can be created and shared, flowing as from a spigot, shouldn’t we all have access to it for the greater benefit of society? Isn’t that all the more reason to endorse open-weight, open-source AI that we can run and train and adapt and control and benefit from on our own? 

    Yes, free, open-weight models will always be two steps (read: six months) behind the so-called frontier models. But open models will be able to do 99 percent of what 99 percent of people want to do with AI. Still, there will be business opportunities aplenty for AI companies to build specialized models, trained on specialized information, for specialized tasks of high value. In fact, it would be much more productive if the companies would concentrate on that instead of pursuing their bullshit goal of building “artificial general intelligence.” 


    Now I’d like to take this discussion one step more: If “intelligence” is a public good, should not the data needed to train models be? For if we all can benefit from open models, who would want them to be less intelligent? And does it not follow them that data, civic information, and by extension journalism should be open? 

    Oh, I can hear the howls of protest, for I’ve heard them for years: How will the gathering of that data and information be paid for? One answer is universities, where research is subsidized. Or it was, until America’s right-wing extremists opened war against the institutions of education and science. 

    As for journalism, it is not a forever thing. Before the economics of mass media and the attention economy overtook news and civic discourse, society operated differently. Limited by the technologies of the time, before steam-powered presses and Linotypes, publications were small, often both created and shared socially. Now that mass media and its attention economy are the walking dead, we will need to reconsider every model of gathering, sharing, and utilizing public information. My point is that the discussion about open-weight, open-source AI forces us to ask similar questions about what open journalism would look like. Eh, comrades?

  • To redefine progress

    In an urgent and provocative essay in Die Zeit, journalist Georg Diez calls for a redefinition of progress in the time of AI. Taking lessons from the genesis of progressivism — a response to the Industrial Revolution and the (first) Gilded Age — we cannot now surrender the power to decide society’s future to present technologists.

    “A notion of progress that inspires society and supplies it with new energy, both intellectually and emotionally, must therefore be comprehensive, systemically conceived, and grand,” Diez writes (with apologies for my translation). “It must be formulated collaboratively by politics, business, science, and civil society, and it must answer the question of what technology we want — and under what terms.”

    I write this just as the ultimate profanity of capitalism’s coupling with technology — Elon Musk’s SpaceX — comes to the market at the absurd and obscene valuation of $2.11 trillion. Thus he, the world’s richest man, is funded and empowered to define progress according to his insanities: colonizing Mars and beyond with the seed of his loins and fevered dreams.

    We cannot let this stand.

    Diez asserts that “the situation is schizophrenic. On the one side, large swathes of Western societies seem to have lost faith that the future will be better. On the other side, a techno-optimist progress cult has established itself in Silicon Valley, promising incredible prosperity and undreamed-of convenience for all, because artificial intelligence will enable a giant leap in productivity.”

    These extreme worldviews preempt reasoned public discourse over progress’ direction. “What does it mean,” Diez asks, “especially for a society that is experiencing the end of its old certainties, without having yet found new ones?” He says that in the past, progress equaled “technology plus values” and society was able to negotiate “how the advantages and gains of technological progress could and should be distributed.” I’m not so sure we’ve done such a good job of it of late. Still, he is right to add that today, we must recognize changed circumstances: the decline of the West in the face of advances by China, India, and Indonesia. “This makes it all the more urgent to formulate a concept of progress for the 21st Century.”

    For this, Diez turns to the 19th Century, to the Industrial Revolution and the impact of the era’s coal, steel, and railway barons. “Driven by the first Industrial Revolution, a technological and economic transformation produced both mass proletarian misery and stark wealth.” Resistance to both gave birth to the politics of progress.

    I write about a slice of this history in my upcoming book Hot Type, tracking the response of America’s oldest national labor organization, the International Typographical Union (ITU), as it was faced with the imminent arrival of the typesetting machine, the Linotype, in 1886. Having learned from the failures of the Luddites and Captain Swift against mechanical feudalism, as against the eventual perseverance of pressmen at the advent of steam, the union did not fight technology but instead insisted on controlling it and benefiting from its efficiencies, while leading the national movement for the eight-hour day and safer working conditions. The ITU flourished in pay and power until faced with a next technology it could not control (for that story, you’ll have to order the book).

    Such was a spirit of “militant optimism,” in Diez’ words. “Progress, as was clear then and should be clear now, can only be achieved with technology, not against it.” The task is to balance certainly legitimate criticism of technology with a clear vision for how its fruits might benefit society.

    The difference today, Diez says, citing VC Vinod Khosla, is that AI will shift the distribution of power and wealth to capital, away from labor. In response, Khosla proposes exempting the lowest-paid workers from income tax, making up the difference taxing capital gains; various AI boys have touted a universal guaranteed income. But note well that in his encyclical, Pope Leo XIV rejected the latter, for “work is not simply an instrument; it expresses and enhances the dignity of our lives.” Redistribution of wealth is imperative — see: the trillionaire — and should occur through taxation to support social programs.

    A new concept of progress, Diez argues, must be conceived from the perspective of humanity. Amen. This is why I work on new educational programs that emphasize the humanities in the time of AI. And this is what inspired me to edit a new book series called Intelligence: AI & Humanity, to open the discussion to writers from the humanities and social sciences.

    “Artificial intelligence challenges us to redefine who we want to be, both as individuals and as a community,” Diez observes. “It provokes questions such as: What constitutes quality of life for us?… A new concept of progress should be shaped neither by technophobia and austerity nor by the promise of exponential growth.”

    Today, it has been left to the technologists — to the wrong sorts of technologists, often sophomoric dropouts: the Musks, Altmans, Thiels, Karps, Zuckerbergs, Bezoses— to impose their ideas of progress on the rest of us. There is no better example lately than Anthropic positioning itself as savior of humankind, touting its AI “constitution,” while building what it deemed to be AI so dangerous it could not be revealed to mere citizens — prompting Trump to ban it to foreigners, resulting in turning it off for all. This is not progress. 

    No, progress must be the result of open public discourse and political discernment and negotiation. In the 19th Century, trade unions fought for their share of newly created wealth while social movements fought for justice: abolition and suffrage. Today, the debate over the limits and fruits of technology must be driven by new leaders representing the rest of the world outside Silicon Valley.

    This is not to say that technologists should not be parties to the discussion. They should take part in the conversation based on the merit of their work and ideas, not their market caps. But as I have learned in researching and writing my histories of technology and media — of print, magazines, the mechanization and industrialization of mass media, and even the internet — one clear lesson I have taken away is that once a technology becomes commonplace and is put to use by others, the technologists inevitably fade into the background. They hold their power of as priests only temporarily, so long as their mysteries may prevail. This fall from the heights, I predict, will be their fate much faster in the case of AI, because it is the tool made so simple anyone can use it, and because so many of its masters are so deservedly disliked.

    And that is why I share Diez’ arguments with you, for I agree that it is vital that we — workers, students, academics, creators, citizens — take charge of this new technology and of the discussion about its effects. We must define progress not in terms of the AI boys’ bullshit — AGI (artificial general intelligence), ASI (artificial superintelligence), the end of labor, the colonization of unlivable Mars, a world post-humans — but in human terms: dignified work; shared wealth; the benefits of science, art, and creativity; education for all; equity and justice; and community. It is our future we need to map, a task far too vital to leave to programmers and capitalists.