The tyranny of length

The tyranny of length
: Matthew Yglesias argues that the NY Times’ (and other papers’) 800-word standard length for columnists is the curse of the form. Right. I’m not sure whether he’s arguing that shorter or longer is better. Of course, the right answer is, “depends.” Some arguments require more. But most — most — require less. Longer is not smarter. Shorter is harder to write but easier to read and that’s good for us.

When you hear newspaper people talk about serving younger readers — a topic addressed by the head of Tribune Company at the Online News confab — they act as if things need to be shorter to dumb them down for the younger audience, as if their attention span were the problem. No, they’re busy; they have better things to do than read filler blather. Short is good, most times.

3 responses to “The tyranny of length”

  1. mary hodder Avatar

    Well, maybe it’s that articles begin to be written in a digital media style, with say (avg) 8 – 100 word ideas, where those thoughts can be put together for a paper based article, and are kept together for archival (and deeper or more academic) purposes on the web, but then are also marked up with xml or rdf to be searched, recombined, or repurposed, but also to stand on their own for uses more day-to-day (practical) by readers on mobile devices or other reasons for wanting the info chopped up and in chunks. Not every idea or piece of writing has to stand together, but there are reasons to link things together to keep coherency, flow, interest, and argument, but that too can exist in the metadata markup tags. On the other hand, long (21,000 word) articles can exist too, and are necessary for some topics. But thinking about this and allowing many solutions, depending on type of content and need for useful information, will get us to more useful digital info.

  2. Dann Avatar

    I’ve become the master of the 400-600 word “letter to the editor”. (the local paper is generous that way) I’d gladly trade up to an 800 word regular column if someone is hiring!
    -Regards

  3. old maltese Avatar
    old maltese

    Interesting, Mr. Jarvis.
    Could you expand on your thesis?
    :•)