You tell ’em, John

You tell ’em, John
: John McCain talks truth on Iraq in Sunday’s Washington Post:

Iraq is not Vietnam. There is no popular, anti-colonial insurgency in Iraq. Our opponents, who number only in the thousands in a country of 23 million, are despised by the vast majority of Iraqis. The Iraqi insurgents do not enjoy the kind of sanctuary North Vietnam, Cambodia and Laos provided. They do not have a superpower patron. These murderers cannot carry the banner of Iraqi nationalism, as Ho Chi Minh did in Vietnam for decades.

But if we are to avoid a debate over who “lost” Iraq, as we debated who lost Vietnam a generation ago, we must act urgently to transform our early military success into lasting political victory….

The United States will fail in Iraq if our adversaries believe they can outlast us….

Politics at home has handicapped our progress. Today some Democrats who supported the war in Iraq oppose spending the money required to win the peace. Others blindly criticize the administration without proposing an alternative policy that preserves U.S. interests.

With the exception of Joe Lieberman and Dick Gephardt, who are committed to victory in Iraq, it is unclear what the other Democratic presidential candidates would do differently to ensure an American victory — or how they would handle the consequences of the early American withdrawal some advocate. Howard Dean has expressed ambiguity about the justness of our cause in Iraq. I hope he will learn that partisan anger is no substitute for moral clarity.

Read the rest.

7 responses to “You tell ’em, John”

  1. hackjammer Avatar

    “With the exception of Joe Lieberman and Dick Gephardt, who are committed to victory in Iraq, it is unclear what the other Democratic presidential candidates would do differently to ensure an American victory…”
    Wesley Clark favors committing more troops to Iraq.
    And Iraq is like Vietnam in that the guerillas are lurking among the civilian population.

  2. Charlie Avatar

    And Iraq is like Viet Nam in that they don’t speak English there. And it’s not in the Western hemisphere.
    Jesus.

  3. infamouse Avatar
    infamouse

    I guess Saudi Arabia is just like Vietnam as well. Afterall, they’re lurking among the populace blowing shit up.

  4. Yehudit Avatar

    I always liked John McCain . . . .

  5. Oliver Avatar

    Usually McCain is the only Republican around to make any sense, but in this case he’s adding to the GOP attempt to smear Democrats as wanting to pull out – when it just isn’t true. Dean, Clark, Kerry, Edwards, Lieberman, and Gephardt all have accepted and acknowledged that we cannot retreat from Iraq. This is quite contrary to current moves by the Bush team to get the hell out.

  6. Charlie Avatar

    Which is why Bush didn’t propose $87 billion to support the WOT and the Democrats forced it on him.

  7. michael ledeen Avatar
    michael ledeen

    We cannot win in Iraq so long as the mullahs are in power in Tehran and the Baathists rule Syria. This is a regional struggle, not a national one. The Iranian and Syrian people hate their regimes, and would (will) fight very aggressively for their freedom if they saw real support coming from us, and if (when) they see us winning in Iraq (which means defeating the schemes of the terror masters in Tehran and Damascus).
    The regimes know that, and consequently have launched a terror war against us in Iraq.
    The president is right to say that the issue is freedom, and that if freedom spreads, the terrorists will be more vulnerable. But every time he says something like that, the secretary of state sends another group of diplomats to Geneva to schmooze up the mullahs, thereby betraying the Iranian freedom movement.
    And costing lives of Iraqis and Americans in Iraq.
    McCaine is right to emphasize the urgency of victory, but he needs to expand his strategic analysis to the whole region.