Reparations and racism

Reparations and racism
: I’ve long dismissed the fringe calls for reparations payments for slavery for many reasons — because the sins of the fathers are not the sins of the gerat-great-grandchildren, because many (perhaps most) Americans today are descended from people who came here after the Civil War (how do you determine who should pay and who should be paid?), and mostly because this feeling of entitlement via suit has to end somewhere: The logical and absurd extension of this, I’ve always said, is that the Jews should sue the Egyptians for reparations for slavery under Pharoah.

Well now, Via Memri, the service that translated Middle Eastern media, here is an absurd and sick twist on that: The Egyptian weekly Al-Ahram Al-Arabi interviewed Dr. Nabil Hilmi, dean of the faculty of law at the University of Al-Zaqaziq, who is working on a lawsuit on behalf of Egyptians in Switzerland against “all the Jews of the world” because, when they fled Egypt, they took with them gold and cooking utensils.

The theft was not limited to gold alone. The thieves stole everything imaginable. They emptied the Egyptian homes of cooking utensils. One of the women approached Pharaoh, her eyes downcast, and said that her Jewish neighbor [don’t you mean “slave?” -ed] who lived in the house on the right of her house had come to her and asked to borrow her gold items, claiming she had been invited to a wedding

5 responses to “Reparations and racism”

  1. Mike G Avatar

    Of course, no comment on reparations for the Jewish slaves. How about they get to keep the pyramids they built, then?
    Frankly, I think this is good because it exposes the foolishness of reparations for any but the living who actually experienced something. I wish we had a Native American reparations movement, too. I bet black support for reparations would plummet once they realized how much they, who are fundamentally integrated into the mainstream economy and share in it (whatever barriers still remain), would owe Indians, who are the one group in this country that is still largely isolated from it.
    And then there’s Dick Gregory’s comment that if reparations were truly apportioned based on black blood, there’d be a lot of black people disappointed when they only got a 50% check, and a lot of white people startled to get a 10% or 20% check…

  2. Yehudit Avatar

    Someone emailed me about this article and suggested I compare it to Talmud Tractate Sanhedrin 91a. Very interesting.
    Apparently there was some discussion among the Jewish sages whether the Israelites did indeed steal the gold and utensils, and they come up with some rationalizations for it.
    Also, it seems Arab seething and whining (as they say on LGF) isn’t new:

    On one occasion the Egyptians lodged a complaint against the people of Israel before Alexander the Great . They said to him : Is it not written: ‘and the Lord gave the people favor in the eyes of Egypt’ and they complied? Now give us back the silver and gold which you took from us … He said to them: I too will bring you proof from the Torah, for it is written: ‘And the sojourn of the Israelites who dwelt in Egypt was four hundred and thirty years’. Give us compensation for the labor of 600,000 men whom you enslaved in Egypt for four hundred and thirty years … They searched but could find no answer.

    Heh.
    Not to mention that there isn’t any solid proof the Exodus story happened (we don’t have reliable archeological evidence of Hebrews until about 800 BCE). But we do have solid evidence of the Jews’ treatment at the hands of Muslims and Christians throughout the Middle Ages and renaissance, and then the expulsion of Jews from Arab lands in the mid 20th c., so I would say whatever gold we took from Egypt 4000 years ago is a drop in the bucket of what they owe us, if we wanted to play that game.
    So the Arabs would be smart to drop the issue – if we took them seriously we could bankrupt them.

  3. button Avatar

    Maybe this was tongue-in-cheek and meant to be facetious…? Do you think that’s possible…?

  4. Troll King Avatar
    Troll King

    Ok, here’s my plan. Everybody chips in the world chips in fifty bucks to a pot. That adds up to $300 billion for reparations. Then we elect representatives from each ethnic group. On a specially selected month, each rep will go on worldwide television and tell a long, sad story about their ancestors’ suffering. Whoever has the saddest story that creates the most weeping, wins and gets to distribute any way they see fit these Universal Reparations For All Wrongs Committed By All Ancestors Ever.
    My money’s on the Irish.

  5. MICHAEL SHANNON Avatar
    MICHAEL SHANNON

    Every article on this story traces back to a translation of an Arabic interview done on 08/09/03. The translation was by MEMRI, and almost all sources quote it. MEMRI is based in Washinton DC, and is run by six former Israeli intelligence officers (articles questioning this group have appeared often). An Arabic speaking friend of mine could not find any interview in Al-Ahram with Dr. Hilmy, and I scanned all their English translations with no results…