The persecution of Hoder

Very troubling news about Hossein Derakhshan, the Iranian blog pioneer known online as Hoder: He received a prison sentence of 19.5 years in Iran for being an “anti-revolutionary blogger.”

I’m personally heartbroken. I first met Hoder online when I happened upon his blog as he announced that another Iranian blogger, Sina Motalebi, had been arrested. Sina, who is now working for the BBC in London, just emailed me, by coincidence, when I asked below about the idea of publicness. Sina had announced in public on his blog that he had been summoned to the police. Hoder blogged it. I did. Many others did. He believes that public attention helped get him out of prison and enabled him to escape the country.

Hoder’s story is much more complicated. When I met him online, he was in Canada, where he’d become a citizen. Some gave him credit for starting the amazing Iranian blogosphere; others don’t. He has always been controversial. He was critical of the Iranian regime. He went to Israel and made friends (and lost friends) there — which is one of his so-called crimes: “cooperation with hostile states, propagating against the regime, propagation in favor of anti-revolutionary groups, insulting sanctities, and implementation and management of obscene websites.” Then, just as suddenly, he turned the other way and started supporting Iran’s government and even its right to have nuclear weapons. He asked me to link to posts that made such statements. I was over my head in Iranian politics as I heard other online expats criticize him. I wasn’t sure what to do.

Then Hoder mysteriously returned to Iran. Some say he’d been given assurances that he’d be OK. Others say that he is caught in a power struggle. Again, I know too little. He was arrested two years ago. His family stayed silent in hopes that things would work out. That’s why I said nothing.

But now he has been sentenced. No matter what his opinions were or what opinions you may have had about him, that doesn’t matter now. We should all be outraged, loudly outraged. For — as I said when Hoder told me about Sina’s arrest — a blogger, one of us, has been arrested and imprisoned for what he has said. If anyone should stand up for the right of free speech of a blogger it should be us, bloggers.

What to do? Ethan Zuckerman suggests we pressure Canada to pressure Iran for his release. On the Media reports (when there were still rumors that Hoder could have received the death penalty) that Iran does not recognize dual citizenship. The Canadian government is protesting:

“We are deeply concerned about the news of this severe sentence,” Canadian Foreign Affairs Minister Lawrence Cannon said. “If true, this is completely unacceptable and unjustifiable.”
“No one should be punished anywhere for simply exercising one’s inherent right to freedom of expression,” he said, adding that “Iran must release him.”

The Globe and Mail editorialized for his freedom:

Mr. Derakshan’s views and ways may not be to everyone’s liking – he doesn’t fit neatly as either a state propagandist or an agitator for democracy. But free speech is often inconvenient; indeed, that is one of the reasons why free people should be agitating for his release.

: Here is my original post announcing Sina’s arrest as reported by Hoder. (Please ignore the damned spam links in my archives; I don’t know how to clean them up.)

  • Pingback: Iranian Blogger Hossein Derakhshan Sentenced to 19.5 for Being “Anti-Revolutionary Blogger” | Media and Tech()

  • The Iranian regime sucks.

  • The free speech issues must transcend the issues of Iranian politics, no matter his position on those subjects. Canada must step up to protect him. Thank you for your personal history regarding the timetable of events, and the links you provided as well.

  • Paul

    The last sentence of the Canadian statement is interesting. I wonder what Mark Steyn and Ezra Levant think of it.

  • soheil

    Heard you taking about hoder on twig , i use to be a tech journalist & blogger in Iran and therefore i am very familiar with the problems Iranian regime makes for bloggers in various aspects. it is true that hoder was teh father of blogging in Iran what is not true is that he is in prison because of his blog. hoder had a lot of information about supports western NGO s & governments send to Iranian individuals and organizations which were fighting for human rights in Iran at the time. For a motive i canot understand he choose to give up this information to Iranian officials & secret services. a lot of human organizations was totally melt down and a lot of people ended up answering police and even dozen of them ended in jail and eventually had to left Iran in very bad shape leaving behind everything tehy have got for their own lives. hoder is a victim but he done his bad part too so I think the reason Canadian government doesn’t really want to get involve because nobody knows what hoder shady deal with Iranian regime is. he is in prison because he made deal with devil and obviously the deal gone very bad and Iranian regime used his blog as an excuse to keep him in prison; because they didnt want him free so he cannt gave up their information.

  • Pingback: The persecution of Hoder « Keithpp's Blog()

  • Eerily reminiscent of Soviet persecution of Aleksandr Solzhenitsyn; bloggers evidently aren’t immune to totalitarian repression.

  • Pingback: Listen to 'The persecution of Hoder' narrated by professionals, from 'BuzzMachine' - Hear a Blog()

  • Good morning
    I wanted to also provide some support for freedom of expression in the world. Sorry for my English.
    Thank you very much
    Ignacio Jaen