Defending their own

Defending their own

: The debut NY Times business column on blogs takes the opportunity to defend newspapers against blogs:

A reporter for The New York Times, she writes, “is just a blogger who happened to attend college; impress some bosses with his or her talent; get some training through experience – and possibly (though certainly not always) journalism school; and receive a podium for his or her pains.”

Which is a little like saying a lawyer is just someone who likes to argue who happened to go to law school, pass the bar, and get a job at a law firm. There is little doubt that blogs are transforming the news media, mostly in positive ways. But what the “blogs will destroy the media business” argument misses is that there are fundamental economic reasons that it can never happen.

And just why is that?

It’s not necessarily that blogs become a new force to challenge newspapers and bring them to their knees. It’s that newspapers’ business models — the very thing the columnist thinks is their salvation, without explaining how — are vulnerable. Sing along: plummeting classified revenue, falling retail ad revenue, declining audience, new competition. This creates a competitive void into which blogs and the internet can march… unless newspapers stop trying to keep them at bay, and instead finds the ways to embrace and take advantage of this great new source of news, information, and diverse viewpoints. See a new newsroom.

4 responses to “Defending their own”

  1. Michael Tippett Avatar

    Another difference between the NYTimes reporter and regular bloggers is that bloggers have been, well, blogging. It seems to me that some experience in the blogosphere is worth something – perhaps more – than doing time behind the podium.

  2. Joanne Jacobs Avatar

    A lawyer is someone who was graduated from college and law school. Most journalists are college graduates but it’s not necessary to study journalism to get a job. I majored in English and Creative Writing, then worked in mainstream media for 28 years.
    A lawyer has to pass the bar, a rigorous test of knowledge. A journalist faces no such test.

  3. Lisa Williams Avatar

    It’s funny, I was just listening to Ana Marie Cox’s (Wonkette’s) session at SXSW in my car (the podcast is up at ITConversations.com), and one of the things she said that she admired is that journalism is an uncredentialed profession. Unlike lawyers, as Joanne points out, journalists aren’t required to attend a particular kind of school or be licensed.
    I agree with Cox, I think it lends the profession a dynamism and inclusiveness that you won’t find in The Professions with a capital P (doctor, lawyer. In defense of the professions, there’s a reason why we have licensing and why that kind of freewheeling approach is not what you want in a doctor or a lawyer).
    The more I see of the net the more I realize that talent is not rare. Distribution resources used to be rare, and that made us think that only a small number of people had talent. I remember the first time I walked into a megabookstore, and I couldn’t imagine a bigger bookstore. Through reading the works of many online I now realize I could make a bookstore ten times as big with no reduction in quality. While it’s true there are a lot of mediocre blogs, that’s not news: the fact that there’s an amazingly large number of good ones is. There’s a lot of untapped talent on this globe.
    The other canard is that bloggers don’t report. It’s true that a lot of bloggers just point at MSM stories. But just this morning I did actual reporting for my local journalism website. A phone pole fell on a house. I went, I took pictures, I talked to the neighbors. Real reporting does happen outside of the newsroom.

  4. henrycopeland Avatar

    Credentials? Interesting to note that while many journalists lack any deep expertise or training (not necessarily bad preparation when you’ve got to write about 10 different topics a week), most A-list bloggers write from a foundation of decades of knowledge and training in a particular discipline. Bloggers are lawyers, PhDs, business execs, programmers, entrepreneurs, political operatives, marketing mavens, deepgeeks… tough competition for the average communications major.