Save the F man

Save the F man

: I am glad to see a movement swelling to save Arthur Chi’en, the hapless WCBS reporter who, not knowing he was on the air, asked a couple of bozos shilling for the Opie & Anthony show who were trying to mess up his report, “What’s your fucking problem, man.” Everyone writing about this, including Chi’en himself, first falls down saying that was stupid and regretable and wrong. But was it worth firing the man?

All he did was say fucking.

Have we come to the point in this country when we honestly think that a word that has lost all meaning, just a word, is going to cause the downfall of the nation and is worth a man’s career?

Perspective, people!

What’s offensive is that we let the offended run the world.

Well, now I’m offended. WCBS should not have buckled under to pressure — anticipated pressure at that — just because of one stupid word.

It is time to send a message back to the fringies and tell them that they have their priorities all out of wack.

A blogger named Sergio D. Caplan started a site to Save Arthur Chi’en with instructions for calling WCBS or just using this form; that’s what I’m doing (though, amazingly, they don’t have a link to send a message to the news department — the one department that should be listening to the public!).

This week, Clyde Haberman wrote a column in The Times drawing attention to the issue this week and reporting that fellow reporters are dismayed and that the communications director of the transportion authority complained to the station. It’s a cause.

So join me in writing to WCBS and defending not just Arthur Chi’en but sanity.

It is insane that you fire Arthur Chi’en for one simple, fucking word. It’s just a word, people. You throw out a man’s career. You buckle under to the fringe. You embarrass yourself. You insult your audience (what, you think we can’t take care of ourselves?). Because of one fucking word. For shame. Bring back Arthur Chi’en!

: I STAND CORRECTED: He actually said, “What the fuck’s your problem, man?” The stories about this were so coy, it was impossible to tell and I parsed it wrongly. For grammar, give me an F.

24 responses to “Save the F man”

  1. John LeBlanc Avatar

    Did the reporter get fired for dropping the f-bomb, or did he get fired for an infraction of his employment contract?
    Regardless the word used or anyone else’s opinion of its relative offensiveness, if the contract between the reporter and WCBS covered that territory, and the reporter ostinsibly agreed to be bound by the terms of the contract when he accepted employment from WCBS, why complain he got fired for it?
    Just a question.
    What is defined as offensive, when it comes to the public airwaves, is a consensus of public opinion. The consensus remains squarely against dropping f-bombs on network television. For fans of the word, there’s always cable television. Or blogs.
    John

  2. Jon Avatar

    According to the Chi’en F-Bomb standard, Vice President Cheney should have been s**tcanned.
    Then again, according to the Newsweek standard, the White House should have apologized for it.

  3. Jon Avatar

    Speaking of subjective standards for what constitutes “offensive” content, it is certainly enjoyable to see the conservatives on both sides of the Paris Hilton ad dust-up.
    While the Parents Television Council is up in arms, it would seem that Powerline must be just fine with it.

  4. Undertoad Avatar

    Good for Powerline.

  5. frank Patrick Avatar

    It was hard to choose an appropriate recipient in CBS’ pulldown list on their email comment page. That lack of clarity led me to send it to the one that fit the situation the best — Shame On You!

  6. Connor Peterson Avatar
    Connor Peterson

    >>> asked a couple of bozos shilling for the
    >>> Opie & Anthony show who were trying to
    >>> mess up his report
    Wrong… it was only one bozo from the Opie and Anthony. The other was a bozo from the Howard Stern show. YES… that was Crazy Cabbie who just happened to be in the area… he is the one that says “Suck” (referring to O&A). I wonder why Howard didn’t talk about this at all on his show. One of his bozo’s getting a reporter fired… the old Howie would have ran with it. Howard has turned into a boring old lady.
    See “CBS Reporter Drops the F Bomb” on ifilm: http://www.ifilm.com/viralvideo

  7. supremecorrectorexcelciesmagnificior Avatar
    supremecorrectorexcelciesmagnificior

    Actually, it was “What the f**k’s your problem, man?”, not “What’s your f**king problem, man?”

  8. Terry Heaton Avatar

    What I find most deplorable about this story are the circumstances under which the naughty word was uttered. It is, frankly, hypocritical to send people out to do irrelevant live shots in predictable places — thereby inviting idiots to exploit the live camera — and then turn around a FIRE somebody when the inevitable happens.
    This is shame on WCBS-TV.

  9. Ed Poinsett Avatar
    Ed Poinsett

    I had the same problem Frank Patrick did in deciding where to send my email. I also chose “Shame On You” as I couldn’t identify the “News Department” that Jeff recommended sending the mail to.

  10. Casey Avatar

    While I think it would be stupid if the poor guy got fired I don’t think this is anything new. I don’t think this is a matter of coming to any kind of point in this country. Ten, fifteen years ago this guy would have been fired immediately. Its a sign of progress that he’s still holding on. I think you risk going to far in your outrage over outrage lately. Not everything is a matter of extremist prudes, sometimes things are just working themselves out. I’m sure its been policy on the channel for the last 30 years that cussing is a serious matter regardless of the situation. That’s just how it is, nothing new.

  11. Reid Avatar

    Very interesting. Throughout March and April of last year, Jeff wrote a lot about the use of the “F-word” in relation to FCC censorship and Howard Stern. Yet all quoted references on this site to “fuck” became “f**k,” and we weren’t even supposed to spell it out in the comments.
    Today, Jeff’s putting “fucking” on the front page himself, even offering a correction of the actual grammatical usage of the word, in defense of a TV reporter … who was egged into saying it by one of Stern’s pack.
    That’s progress … of some sort.

  12. John Avatar

    The guy holding up the sign was an intern for the Opie & Anthony Show, which has it’s studio about three blocks from the site where Chi’en was doing his stand-up. It’s also right near the WXRK studios, where Crazy Cabbie was leaving after doing his night shift. Since O&A and Stern get along about as well as Ann Coulter and Michael Moore, Cabbie was actually giving the finger to the O&A intern when he walked towards the subway station and into the shot, adding the “suck” line. But the part about Cabbie being the other guy in the shot didn’t come out until much later.
    I haven’t seen any comment from Chi’en whether it was just the O&A sign that set him off, or if it was seeing Cabbie give the middle-finger salute and use the word “suck” that caused him to turn around and drop the F-bomb to WCBS’s 6 a.m. viewers. But I am surprised that Howard didn’t make a big deal about this — especially since he’s been making such a big deal about trying to get out of his Infinity contract early to move over to Sirius. Taking credit, even indirectly, for getting a fellow Viacom employee fired and leaving CBS open to even more problems with the FCC would seem to be one way of doing that, but I guess Stern would rather keep quiet about the incident rather than give Opie & Anthony any free publicity (and in the shock-jock world, “bad” publicity is usually good publicity among the 18-45 male demographics those shows are trying to attract).

  13. carsonfire Avatar

    While I’m all for saving the guy’s job, it does strike me that there are certain habits that people should eschew depending on their professions. A surgeon shouldn’t be in the habit of playing mumblety pegs before surgery, for instance.
    It’s not that hard to avoid saying f*ck in your daily routine. If you’re on TV a lot, it’s probably a good idea to get out of the habit of dropping the f-bomb just because you think the camera’s not on, or else you prove yourself to be a stupid sh*thead when the camera *is*.
    Again, here’s hoping that the stupid sh*thead can just apologize and get his gig back. And he should then practice cleaning up his daily vocab so it doesn’t happen again, regardless of heckling.

  14. sergio caplan Avatar

    i’m one of the sites that jeff puts in his article, and am just so ashamed of how poorly it was written that i had to use any excuse to comment back and try and save some face.
    as for the comment about chi’en probably having a clause in his contract that says he can get fired for using improper language i am sure it exists.
    that doesn’t mean he “had” to be fired. as i said before, it’s not like he let loose with explitives to make his report more colorful.
    he was harrased, pushed, and egged on, and had a split second of letting his emotions rule, how dare he!
    but in the end, and please hear me out, and if you agree write to the FCC, the fault belongs to WCBS and therefore the FCC should impose a fine!
    using WCBS’s logic, there is no excuse for what happened, and the FCC should fine them. afterall, WCBS said that chi’en broke the rules and there is no excuse for it, and he just got fired!
    and to make it worse, this is even more WCBS’s fault, because they decide to do “live” broadcasts, and have to expect, and therefore should be held responsible for whatever might happen!
    but the FCC did NOT fine them. to the best of my knowledge, they let them pass. why couldn’t WCBS do the same?

  15. G. Hamid Avatar

    This is just a symptom of the many Americans trying to create a painless utopia. There is utterly no difference between the two major parties in their approach to free speech, property rights, drugs, alcohol, cigarettes, firearms, product safety, and damn near anything else they want to go after. If one party says all bars must have a no-smoking section, the other party will then demand no-smoking at all. Get caught with a joint, 1 year mandatory, no 2, do I hear 5, now 10… Say “fuck’in” and you lose your job.
    Chi’en is lucky that’s all that’ll happen to him, though who knows yet. The FCC might still crucify him financially.
    Get used to this, folks, because there’s only one difference between the Republicans and Democrats anymore. One wants to take your money then put you in jail, the other wants to put you in jail then take your money.
    You figure out which is which, ’cause I just don’t give a fuck anymore.

  16. Vox Avatar

    Don’t you think it is time to remove this from your sidebar

    No personal attacks, hate speech, bigotry, or seven dirty words in the comments or comments will be killed along with commenters

    In light of your ever increasing comfort level with at least one of those seven words, isn’t it just a bit hypocritical?

  17. G. Hamid Avatar
    G. Hamid

    RE: Commenting Rules
    I did not see the rule prior to my comment. I apoligize and restate my last sentence thusly:
    “You figure out which is which, ’cause I just don’t care anymore.”
    The other occurance of the offending word in my comment was not a use of it, but rather a reference its use elswhere.

  18. John LeBlanc Avatar

    Sergio Caplan writes: “that doesn’t mean he “had” to be fired. as i said before, it’s not like he let loose with explitives to make his report more colorful. he was harrased, pushed, and egged on, and had a split second of letting his emotions rule, how dare he!”
    There are tens of thousands of professionals who, every day, manage to stifle what I am sure is sometimes the overwhelming desire to do and say any number of things that would satisfy the immediate urge to do so. It’s not a matter of cutting the guy some slack. It’s about observing professionalism and decorum as it is currently defined in one venue that still demands a certain brand of it.
    If he’d uttered the word in another forum/venue wherein such language is the norm, this entire discussion wouldn’t be occurring. But he did and these are the consequences of that action.
    I really fail to understand why it is some people appear to believe “free speech” means getting to say anything you want, anytime you want, anywhere you want, without having to face the consequences.
    John

  19. Tom Avatar

    Jeff,
    while I’m fully behind this cause, and think it’s amazingly harsh that this guy got canned for this, I have two points – one, if this was contractual, as a commenter above suggested, there’s not much that can be done. Two, the posting of the form to send comments to CBS is exactly the same kind of effort that you poo-poohed folks behind the PTC for using when they have “filed complaints” with the FCC over various television shows. Now I’m one for ease of doing anything, especially online, but having your cake and denying others its fudgy goodness (sorry, chocolate binge) isn’t the way to go. If we’re going to “email this webpage” it’s no better an individual complaint than those from the PTC are. CBS needs to hear specifically, from each individual, why they are against (or for, as it were) this firing, so they can take it to heart. Otherwise it’s just lemmings to them, and we know this.

  20. Sergio D. Caplan Avatar

    John LeBlanc says: “I really fail to understand why it is some people appear to believe “free speech” means getting to say anything you want, anytime you want, anywhere you want, without having to face the consequences.”
    As I said on my own webpage, I believe cursing is a big thing, something I try to avoid doing period. I never said there should be no consequences. In fact most people’s responses have been, punish him somehow, but don’t just fire him!
    This isn’t about free speech equals getting away with anything anytime. In my opinion, this is about absolutism combined with this incredibly scary shift we seem to be doing towards some really dark conservative forum of “Yes or No”, “Our wya or the highway”, “If you’re not with us, you’re against us.”, etc.
    But I could be wrong, as I said, it doesn’t seem that the FCC is taking that same attitude, it seems they cut WCBS some slack. They seemed to handle this on a “case” basis. They cut WCBS the same slack that WCBS did not offer to Chi’en.
    It just stinks.
    That’s how I see this, anyway.

  21. John LeBlanc Avatar

    Sergio, I’m with you on this: I’d prefer WCBS not have fired him.
    In the 70s, my first broadcast job was as an announcer on an FM radio station. The 5PM newscast was a fifteen minute news block — all read live with the occasional recorded comments.
    On this day, the news director forgot to recue a recorded piece. So in the middle of the newscast, when I hit the button to play it, there was nothing. Crickets.
    I hit the button again, for some reason thinking doing the same action over and over again would somehow get me a different outcome. Again, nothing.
    When I close my eyes and remember the event, I recall clearly how the meters on the mixing console bounced up and down when I said into the microphone, “Oh f*ck.”
    It was a bad day at the office. Maybe not as bad as Sheppard Smith’s “blowjob” remark on FOX News, but a bad day nonetheless. Remarkably, I didn’t get fired either, but then the station wasn’t WCBS, either.
    So, I do feel for the guy. But I’ll still stand by my remarks above.
    John

  22. Cal Avatar

    It’s all about the image. Of course they are going to fire him. Not saying it’s right. Any reporter should know that every mic is hot.

  23. Mike Avatar

    Good for WCBS. There are hundreds of people who will jump at the chance to fill the opening. Hopefully the station will pick someone who is capable of controlling himself in difficult situations and who will honor their employment contract.
    Anyone who works for a big company would be fired for saying the “F” word in public while representing our employer. He got exactly what he deserved.

  24. Jon Rintels Avatar

    I put this in the same category as NBC’s ban of Motley Crue over Vince Neil’s midnight F Bomb on New Year’s Eve, which did not even violate FCC indecency rules as they are not in effect after 10 p.m. There are serious issues raised in both these banning/firing cases concerning the intimidation of media — and self-censorship by the media — to placate the indecency crusaders. We blogged mightily on this at http://www.creativevoices.typepad.com, hope you’ll take a look. Best, Jon Rintels