How advertising really works

How advertising really works

: Howard Stern told great and pathetic stories this morning about trying to get a job when he got out of college: radio guys who listened to his horrible audition tape and told him he was the worst announcer they’d ever heard, a close-miss at becoming a ladies’ buyer at Bloomingdales, and stints with advertising:

He got a job as a media planner at Benton & Bowles. Math skills? they ask. Excellent, he says. And then he arrives at work and knows he’s in over his head. He’s working on Planter’s Peanuts. The boss whips out a calculator and sheets of numbers and tells him to find all the Jewish newspapers in the country — Jews like peanut oil for cooking, he says — and calculate the CPM and then divide. In Howard’s head, he shrieks: “Divide? DIVIDE?!?” He comes in on Saturdays and then Sundays — “you don’t have to wear a tie on Sundays,” somebody tells him (which reminds me of the old working-at-Disney joke: “If you don’t come in on Saturday, don’t bother coming in on Sunday”). He can’t do it. He quits with no notice.

Note that this is how money is divvied up to the titans of media: Some kid out of college who, if he’s lucky, can divide, plans where to spend an advertiser’s bucks.

Howard’s father then got him an in a the B&B film department as the AV geek but he got fired before he was hired because he’d quit his last job there without notice.

And then he got a job in sales at a tiny radio station, where the boss, who wasn’t wearing a shirt, told him to sell advertising and get in-kind trade: Howard went to a Chinese restaurant and convinced the man he had to advertise on radio and he comes back to the office with hundreds of Chinese dinners at the ready when he finds authorities taking documents. He goes back to the Chinese restaurant and tells him never to advertise on radio.

This is how media works.

8 responses to “How advertising really works”

  1. Mike Avatar

    Is it? And why is that because Howard says so? I mean obviously if it happened this way to Howard it obviously happens this way throughout the rest of the industry.
    My sister works in advertising and has been for over 6 years now. I would dare to say that times have changed since Howard was doing these things because what she describes is completely different than the word according to Stern.

  2. Ryan Avatar

    As someone who has worked in the industry for several years now, I can say with full confidence that media planning has gotten a lot more sophisticated and involved than in Howard’s day. The amount of research, planning, and deep thinking that is done prior to making a buy is astounding. If you’d like to believe that media planners are sitting around a room saying, “I think Jews like peanuts,” and then placing multmillion dollar buys around the notion, you’re on some seriously strong drugs.

  3. Paw Avatar

    Stern’s comments, while amusing, aren’t really a reflection of agency life as it is today. As a former Benton and Bowles employee, I can say with some certainty that the college kid crunching the numbers isn’t the decision maker by far. I can also say with certainty that the entry-level media planner/buyer job is difficult, unglamourous and low paying (relative to effort and hours worked in comparison to other service related positions). This is precisely why the quality of entry level job candidate in media diminishes every year. Agency’s clients want more out of their agency every year, including measures of accountabilty relative to product sales (laughable considering some of the products themselves), are always looking to cut fees and will jump between agencies at the drop of a hat. Agency turnover is high, inadequately trained people are promoted via accelerated attrition, resulting in inadequate training for the entry levels, and so on.
    Unfortunately, THAT’S how media planning/buying at agencies works today.

  4. Randy Charles Morin Avatar

    Hey, if anybody wants to buy some banners on my site, I think I have some Jewish readers.

  5. Joel Avatar

    Randy,
    Will you take peanuts in payment?

  6. Cal Avatar

    “Note that this is how money is divvied up to the titans of media: Some kid out of college who, if he’s lucky, can divide, plans where to spend an advertiser’s bucks.”
    I really hope you don’t believe that.

  7. Dexter Westbrook Avatar
    Dexter Westbrook

    I have a high regard for this site, but this post — using a probably apocryphal, and certainly exaggerated, story by Howard Stern as a valid example of “how media works” — is the dumbest I’ve seen in a long time.
    It’s like describing a vacuum tube accident and then declaring at the end, “This is how computers work.”
    Geez.

  8. Jeff Jarvis Avatar

    Some are being a bit too literal today. Of course, this isn’t exactly how it works. But media buying is still done by 22-year-olds without the experience or authority to make strategic decisions and that does, indeed, have an impact on media.
    When I started EW, one of the great benefits of the idea, in the corporate mind, was that it would appeal to 23-year-old media buyers (which, in some ways, mattered more than the audience).
    In any case, folks, it’s Howard. He’s being funny. He’s telling stories about his life. Get it?