TV and me

TV and me

: I came to a shocking realization over the last few days:

I don’t watch broadcast TV anymore.

Now that’s shocking because I love TV. I was the TV critic for TV Guide and People magazines and I created a damned entertainment mag and appeared on TV and watched TV. I kept four VCRs going at once almost every night. I knew what was happening in every corner of prime time. This weekend, when I took my son on the NBC studios tour in New York (our clever avoidance of a visit to the American Girl store with the women of the house), I was the only person in the group who could name every founding cast member of Saturday Night Live. TV was my life. Was.

But here comes the new fall season and, frankly, I couldn’t give a damn. I’m not watching any new series. I’m not following old series. I’m not watching broadcast TV. Three reasons:

1. The internet and the distraction of blogs. I spend a great deal of my day doing just what I’m doing at this second: reading and writing on the internet. I don’t consume media anymore; I live it.

2. Cable is so damned good. There are great shows on cable, especially on HBO, and I watch them with the same devotion I used to give to Cheers or Hill St. Blues and Seinfeld. But The Sopranos and The Wire and Curb Your Enthusiasm are better and more addictive. And even when I’m not watching them, I’m watching niche TV: We love do-it-yourself home improvement shows, for example. As with all other media, one-size-fits all is dead; nice programming — quality niches, special-interest niches, audience niches — are taking over.

3. Broadcast is getting so damned bad. I am not now and never have been and never will be a snob about TV. I look down my nose at people who look down their noses at people who watch TV; I distrust anybody who brags to me that they don’t own a TV or just watch PBS. Bull. But I do have to say that I have not become a regular with The Apprentice or Survivor or American Idol and I do believe that — as with all other trends that threatened to eat TV — these, too shall pass. And then where will the networks be?

All of this is to say that the studies showing a decline in TV viewership tied to an increase in internet usage are right. I’m the damned poster child.

A greater percentage of the Internet households surveyed by the Digital Future Project indicated that they spent less time watching TV in 2003 than previous years. Nearly 38 percent said they spent less time watching television in 2003, compared to 31 percent in 2002, and 33 percent in 2001.

The greatest impact on television viewing was seen among veteran users with 7+ years online, with 45.5 percent saying they watched less since they started using the Internet. In 2001, just 35 percent said the Internet caused them to watch less TV. That swelled to 38 percent in 2002.

Just wait until TV explodes with alternate means of delivery — via the internet — and alternate sources of programming — the citizens. The death of the network age, so often predicted, is upon us.

21 responses to “TV and me”

  1. JohnO Avatar

    It’s nice to hear somebody say that besides me, especially somewhat like you who has actual ties to the industry. I can remember getting the Fall Preview issue of TV Guide and pouring over the new series for the dozen or shows that would grab my interest. This year I literally thumbed through it and tossed it back on the table.
    For myself, the biggest turnoff are all the bleeping reality shows. I love Survivor and it’s still a must watch, but I have absolutely no interest in any of it’s spawn. Nor do I care about CSI East Duluth, CSI Sheboygan or Law & Order Food Safety Division.
    I spend most nights on the computer, usually playing games. The TV is on, but it’s just background noise.

  2. Fausta Avatar

    The only Law & Order I watch is CI, because of the excellently quirky Vincent Donofrio, which reminds me of the also excellently quirky Jeremy Brett as Sherlock Holmes (still available in the Biography channel, if you needed to know). On cable, my addiction to home DIY programs never seems to end.
    So much for broadcast TV.

  3. Harold de Boer Avatar
    Harold de Boer

    The delivery of tv shows via the internet is quite widespread already at this point in time, over several different (p2p)systems. This allows viewers all over the world to watch US tv shows (really almost everything is captured by someone somewhere, and in high quality too) within a day of its broadcast, and sometimes even before. This way, although illegal, you can view what you want when you want it, like the podcasting platform is doing for radio…

  4. Stan Avatar

    My God. I just stopped to think about my TV habits for the last few months and I really do just watch PBS.
    I’m one of them.

  5. Kate Avatar

    I work in TV and I never watch anything but cable. I don’t even have the 2nd dish that allows me to get local networks. Reality on cable (thanks Bravo, thanks BBC-A) is better,too.

  6. mistercalm Avatar
    mistercalm

    My watching habits are Wings (Discovery Wings), Mail Call (History), City Confidential (Court TV), Enterprise (UPN) and Rescue Me (FX). Only UPN might be considered “broadcast”. I have no interest in any show on ABC, NBC, or CBS… Scrubs, occasionally. I am in love with the concept of “narrowcasting” instead of “broadcasting”: trying to be all things to all people is too limiting. I like to pick and choose from a myriad of sources, which makes “news gathering” MY province instead of leaving it to the editors of newspapers or Dan Rather. Isn’t life great? Kinda sucks for the oldline MSM, but great for the consumer.

  7. Jazz Avatar

    Only four or so years ago, I was a network TV addict myself. Now I think the only network show I watch “regularly” would be Survivor, (yes, yes, I know. I’m “lame.” Thank you) and Joan of Arcadia. I don’t know why, but that show really gets my attention.
    We primarily watch the Discovery channel, TLC, History Channel, Comedy Central, and CNN.
    There is one new show this season that has some promise. “Clubhouse.” Simply because I love baseball and it has Christopher Lloyd in it. I saw the pilot last night and it was good enough to give it a few more tries.

  8. Victoria Balfour Avatar
    Victoria Balfour

    With the rare exception, in my opinion, broadcast TV has been bad since the 60s. I only watch cable news, C-Span and reruns of “Cops.”
    Also, Jeff, have you hit 50 yet ? Isn’t it possible that the broadcast television programs are pretty much the same but that as an older viewer, you are suddenly more discriminating and less tolerant of b.s. ?

  9. Tony Alva Avatar

    It is all as abysmal as you describe with the exception of two or three network shows and ALL of the HBO productions.
    There is one element of broadcast TV that has improved through… SPORTS BABY!!!
    I live in the south and it’s all about college football. The networks and lower band cable networks do a great job of providing me plenty of almost free college game day coverage. My wife would probably have other thoughts on this, but it’s all good until end of January. Go Terps!!!

  10. Bob Sassone Avatar

    Look, I love cable too, and I agree network TV isn’t what it used to be, but come on: there’s still a lot to like on the nets.
    How about Letterman? Or other late night shows like “Conan O’Brien” and “Nightline?” I hate reality shows with the heat of a thousand suns, but “Survivor” is always entertaining. “Alias” is one of the best shows on TV in the past 5 years. How about “The Simpsons”? “Everwood”? Or maybe “Arrested Development,” a great show.
    For new shows, “Clubhouse”, “Lost,” and “Jack and Bobby” show a lot of promise. I really like them so far. And there are still a ton of shows yet to premiere…

  11. Tim Windsor Avatar
    Tim Windsor

    Heh! Your Freudian Slip is showing…
    “I created a damned entertainment mag”
    :-)

  12. Tim Windsor Avatar
    Tim Windsor

    Oops. Should have thought about that for a few nanoseconds longer. I read it as missing the word “good” or “fine” after “damned,” when in fact I guess you were saying “I created an entertainment magazine, fer cryin’ out loud!”
    Redfaced and receding into the shadows….

  13. Hunter McDaniel Avatar
    Hunter McDaniel

    For many years I just the networks for sports, and PBS for entertainment. Then it got to the point where there didn’t seem to be that much on PBS either, in between the pledge drives. And I’ve always been to much of a cheapskate to get cable.
    About a year I upgraded to HDTV and started watching a few network shows – mostly the crime dramas – just because they were in HD. I find them entertaining, but not compelling – something I can take or leave.
    But the real revolution in TV viewing for me has been NETFLIX. While tv-across-the-internet seems to be everyone’s dream of future nirvana, Netflix is already delivering a pretty good approximation. I started off using Netflix to watch “movies”, but more and more I use it watch “TV”. Even the HBO series which have Jeff excited these days can be had on Netflix a year later; and with so much good stuff available to watch, what’s so important about seeing something when it first comes out?

  14. Karl Avatar

    I am almost exactly in Jeff’s position regarding my TV habits. However, even though I don’t watch reality shows, I don’t have the animus toward them that most seem to harbor. The early days of TV featured primetime game shows and talent shows, which is what Survivor, The Apprentice, and American Idol are. They went away, started their comeback with Millionaire, and already seem to be on the wane again, given the new offerings this season.
    I find it a little ironic that Jeff gives these shows a “this too will pass” jab in a post where he admits he watches home improvement shows. Perhaps he is as un-handy with home improvement skills as I am, and thus does not see them as reality programming…

  15. Matthew Goggins Avatar
    Matthew Goggins

    We don’t have cable. We use the TV mostly for kiddy shows and for videos. The only regularly scheduled show I turn the tube on for is the re-runs of The Simpsons on the local Fox network.
    But I would watch a lot of other shows if I were a single bum. There’s a lot of good, entertaining TV out there, especially on cable. But there’s just a lot of other things I’d rather do, mainly involving my wife, my son, and/or my computer.

  16. Sterling Avatar

    Oh, God – I used to read your TV Guide reviews. I never put it together until just now.

  17. Rick Ellis Avatar

    As I guy who would be happy having 1/10 of the career you’ve had, I hesitate to disagree.
    But while network TV can be a crapfest of bad entertainment, there are some exceptions.
    Someone else mentioned “Joan Of Arcadia,” and there’s “24” and the new “Lost.” “Alias” is a bit uneven recently, but still generally wonderful.
    Comedy is in a dry spell, but even a reality/home remodeling show like “Extreme Home Makeover” is pretty entertaining.
    I don’t think it’s just narrowcasting that has hurt the quality of broadcast TV. Quite frankly, a lot of it is due to the interference of the network suits.
    Once the syn/fyn rules were eased a few years back, the network’s got into the production side and the result was an entire cottage industry of weasels who have some opinion about what makes good TV. The average producer ends up feeling as if they’re being pecked to death by an endless procession of no-talent ducks. And they end up fleeing to cable, where there is less interference and more of a willingness to experiment.
    Still, nothing explains a horrific show like “Dr. Vegas.”

  18. Jeff Jarvis Avatar

    Just to be clear… My point is not to badmouth broadcast TV. I do think the quality is on a decline with overuse of (a) reality shows and (b) cop franchises. But as ALWAYS happens on TV, these overdoses will fix themselves as the audience gets tired of them. So, yes, I don’t think TV as good today as it was a while back and I think that competition and economics have a lot to do with that.
    Still, my real point is that broadcast TV is simply getting a lower priority in life because of the internet and cable. I have more control over my media and I’m exercising it and in my life, broadcast declines. For ME particularly, that’s saying something just because much of my life has been about TV.

  19. MattB Avatar

    I’ve also mostly abandoned broadcast TV, except for sports, but I happened to catch The Clubhouse on CBS last night and was very pleased. The networks should make more shows like that and fewer like Fear Factor.

  20. Brett Avatar

    I may be the oddball here, but… I’m the guy without a TV, mostly because I find that I don’t need one. (I mooch the occasional Survivor episode from friends when I must. But even that is down this year.)
    What’s more, I have 3 teenagers, and all of them agree with me on this: they don’t miss the TV. My son is busy IM’ing his buddies or over at their house. My daughter goes to my ex’s house for her critical show (Everwood) or she’s with friends or working her job. And my youngest son reads a lot and plays games with dad.
    Like Hunter, we watch any TV (just finished the first 3 seasons of CSI) via DVD rentals (recently dropped Netflix for Blockbuster Unlimited) and as my son puts it – we gather round the family laptop, which is quite adequate. Much better – no commercials.
    TV is not important any more. It’s too passive, too old.

  21. Robert Avery Avatar
    Robert Avery

    I recently reached the same realization — I rarely watch network programs. And those I do watch (I admit it — I’m a “Law & Order” addict; all three and soon to be four versions, and I still laugh out loud at “Raymond”). But I don’t have to watch those shows on network TV (although I do when I can). Sure, sure, I miss the first showing. But they all will be syndicated almost immediately, and soon thereafter will be out on DVD. So I can wath at my leisure (I know, I could always buy a Ti-Vo too). And no show is a national event the way “Lucy” was when I was growing up in the fifties. And network news? Pabulum. And yet we are TV addicts in my house — ten bloody sets in a house for two people (never know when you might want to watch something).