Citytv

winterwhiners.bmpCitytv

: Toronto’s Citytv is a local media pioneer that hasn’t been copied nearly enough in the rest of the world.

I’ve never figured out why. Is it because it’s Canadian and nobody noticed? Naw. Or is it because Citytv wasn’t afraid to come out from behind its wall and talk to people long before anybody else thought of it?

Citytv is media at a human level. And that’s rare.

I’ve been singing that melody in conversations with other media folk lately: Media are institutions: stone monoliths with stentorian names — The Times, The Guardian, National Broadcasting…. The web (and weblogs) cut media down to size: to a human level. They level the playing field. They force big media to look eye-to-eye with their public. They start the conversation.

Citytv did it first. Years ago, the genius behind the station, Moses Znaimer, put a booth on the side of his building on perpetually hip Queen Street West with a video camera and called it the Speaker’s Corner: Put in a loon (a buck), talk to the camera, and it might end up on TV. The people speak. Citytv listens. The people speak. Citytv makes them stars.

It makes great TV. They used to pepper the videos throughout the day. Now they make a show out of it every Saturday night. Go to the site and click on the weather whiners on the right column or on the preview of this week’s show. It’s great stuff.

Citytv calls this the original reality show. It’s also the original vlog.

Citytv also put its studio on street-level — eye-level — long before Today did it. This morning, I ran by at 6:15 a.m. and saw a Korean bell choir inside klanging away. The weather lady was outside doing a live report. I moved to run the other way and the security guy motioned me on to run into the shot. It’s OK. It’s reality.

CityTV now has a local 24-hour news channel and they cleverly borrowed from Bloomberg TV by cramming the screen with useful information: The video feed is only a quarter of the real estate. Elsewhere you always see a four-day forecast (which certainly beats waiting 20 minutes for the weatherman in your market to read the weather… and if you blink, you miss it) and traffic video and headlines and stick tickers and sports scores and entertainment calendars. This is useful TV.

I briefly consulted to an effort to start a local TV news network and I tried to get them to learn from Citytv. I wanted to hear from the people with Speaker’s Corners all over the state. And — also long before Today returned to the street — I wanted to put the studio in a storefront in a mall (since that is now America’s downtown). Didn’t happen. Too bad. It would still make good TV. It makes great TV in Canada still.

11 responses to “Citytv”

  1. Canuck fact checker Avatar
    Canuck fact checker

    Bad photo.
    Citypulse is not City Tv. It’s the competition — CTV!!!!

  2. Jeff Jarvis Avatar

    Thanks. But I got the image from the Citytv site! I thought pulse was the extension of its own brand. Picture replaced.

  3. Jeff Jarvis Avatar

    No, wait a sec: CityPulse is CityTV’s news brand:
    http://toronto.citytv.com/whats_on/cityPulse/index.asp

  4. Robert McClelland Avatar

    City TV also shows Friday night softcore pornos. How’s that for freedom?

  5. roux Avatar

    They’ve been doing it at the Mall of Louisiana in Baton Rouge for a couple of years. Oh they usually pick a topic and it’s free. I can’t remember what they call it but it is pretty lame.

  6. Robert Pointer Avatar

    What a fantastic thing/idea. Thanks for posting that Jeff. Gears are are starting to turn….
    rob.

  7. Kat Avatar

    My God, if you think City TV is great, you don’t require much for taste. Its claim to fame is Ed the sock and a bunch of floozies riding guys for 2 hours breathing hard.

  8. Chuck Olsen Avatar

    I was blown away by CityTV when I was at a broadcast conference in Toronto several years ago. I should say, I was blown away by the concept of CityTV. Moses spoke at our conference, and got me all psyched about a TV station being so connected to people on the street (literally).
    I tried to get our public TV station to follow in their footsteps. We are PUBLIC, after all. Like you, I wasn’t successful. Some interest, but it never really went anywhere.
    Oh – but when I actually watched some CityTV in my hotel room, well… it was pretty bad. Perhaps it’s better now,but it’s important to note that more democratic TV does not automatically mean better TV.

  9. marc weisblott Avatar

    The most inspired years of Citytv were mostly pre-1980, when it was a money-leaking indie UHF that had no choice but to do it all on the cheap, before it was rescued by a radio company, Chum Ltd. They had another wave of new ideas after moving to larger premises in the late-’80s. But, as per the usual media tale, Znaimer was pushed out a couple years ago … and while the entrails of some of those earlier low-budget innovations remain, City is just another dumbed-down branch of just another broadcasting megalith, expanding operations while contracting the number of employees, ad nauseum. It’s nothing special now.

  10. Humbled Canuck Fact Checker Avatar
    Humbled Canuck Fact Checker

    Jeff,
    I am totally humbled. Here in Montreal, the CTV local news is called Pulse and I thought when I recently saw CTV Toronto news it had the same name.
    My bad.
    Apologies

  11. Junktruck Avatar
    Junktruck

    KONG-TV in Seattle has been doing this since the beginning. It started as a goofy promo for the television station and then people started just venting. I think it got pulled quickly after that.
    Junk