Memo to Baghdad bureaus: Get bloggers

Memo to Baghdad bureaus: Get bloggers

: As Howard Kurtz writes today, American reporters in Iraq are pretty much prisoners inside the cloistered confines of the green zone because it’s too dangerous to venture out to where the people — and the news — are.

So here’s a suggestion, guys: Start reading — and quoting — Iraqi bloggers.

You should be doing that anyway, since these folks give us a perspective you big-time reporters simply are not giving us. But you should be doing this especially now that you can’t get out and report the news.

Of course, these aren’t “real journalists.” That means they don’t have suits and expense accounts. But they have eyes and ears and keyboards and they give us a viewpoint we need to see. So you can issue caveats aplenty.

But then read them. Quote them. Share them. Just go to Zeyad’s blog and start clicking on his blogroll to find the brothers Omar, Mohammad and Ali or Ays, Alaa , Raed, Raed’s family, River, Firas Georges, Sam , Kurdo’s World, Sarmad, and Baghdadi (an Iraqi-American who has been back and forth).

They can see what you can’t see, reporters — and isn’t that valuable? They can report what you can’t report — and shouldn’t you seek that out? They have a perspective you don’t have. Read them. Quote them.

20 responses to “Memo to Baghdad bureaus: Get bloggers”

  1. Easycure Avatar

    Frankly, that’s a bunch of crap that it’s “too dangerous to go out there”. We have thousands of civilian contractors out there “in dangerous territory” every day.
    In the past, reporters would go undercover to rget a story. Now they just sit on their butts until they hear something second-hand. For reporters to not go out there themselves shows them for the cowards they have become as a whole.

  2. Eric Akawie Avatar

    I had a similar reaction to easycure when I read that article this morning. I think it’s the opposite reason though- war correspondents are (or think of themselves as) danger junkies. There’s no glory for them in going out into the 98% of the country where they won’t be shot at and doing stories on how well the reconstruction is going.

  3. rktsci Avatar
    rktsci

    The reporters might also have the bloggers come to them for interviews, or better yet, do the interview via email. The bloggers could then post the exchange on their blogs and we can check it against what makes print. Pre-Fisking, as it were.

  4. Andy Avatar

    The fear that bloggers may not be real authentic sources should be tempered with the recent scandals perpetrated by “real” reporters sitting in newsrooms.
    How may lies does a newspaper get before they are a liar? How many false stories, pictures and quotations are allowed before they are no longer worthy of trust?

  5. Angelos Avatar
    Angelos

    Dateline Florida, November 2000.
    It was discovered, and widely repoted in Europe, that 57000 Black and Hispanic voters were scrubbed from voter rolls at the orders of Katherine Harris and Jeb Bush. Some of them, because they were felons – for crimes committed in… 2007! Some of them had committed misdemeanors, like dunk driving, etc., that don’t involve loss of voting priveledges. Some were just guilty of being black.
    Another 40000 who were ACTUAL former felons (who had served their time and thus had obtained clemency, including reinstatement their right to vote), were re-removed from the voter rolls.
    This was well documented beyond doubt, along with affidavits from people witing the database company that managed the voter list.
    Almost 100000 minority and mostly Democratic voters, disenfranchised witha keystroke.
    EVERYONE in the rest of the world, and a couple dozen Salon readers knew about this. But did any major papers or TV news organizations pick this travesty up?
    Well, CBS called Jeb Bush’s office, and they denied it. Oh well.
    WaPo, they called Jeb Bush’s office, and I guess the story didn’t check out.
    The American journalist working for the Guardian, the British paper that broke this and actually did some INVESTIGATING, Greg Palast, offered his proof (including CDs with the databases, and all sworn affidavits and leaked confidential documents) to ANY American news organization that wanted it, even WaPo, the Guardian’s sister newspaper. The work was DONE! But nope, Jeb’s PR flack says it’s not true.
    THAT, my friends, is investigative journalism in the US today.
    You think a guy with a J-school degree is going to listen to a lowly BLOGGER when he can just reprint what (then) Fleischer and (now) McLellan says?

  6. Franky Avatar
    Franky

    Easycure, do you have any evidence for calling the entire press corp a bunch of cowards?

  7. Andrea Harris Avatar

    Franky: the portion of the article quoted above, when compared with the war reporting that other reporters did in the past, often from the midst of battle (which can be looked up in any library, far away from the internet that has so many cruel people lying to you in it), should be quite good enough for someone who actually wants the evidence, but we know you are not one of those so let’s just call this sentence typing practice for me.
    Angelos: X|

  8. Angelos Avatar
    Angelos

    ??

  9. Franky Avatar
    Franky

    Oh what pleasure, Andrea’s here.
    Firstly, I don’t believe you ever read any war reporting. Call it a suspicion, but feel free to inform me of the extensive reading you’ve done on the subject. Secondly, war has been changing over the past decades (I’m sure with all your reading on war as you’ve obviously done, you know this). It wasn’t until the wars of Yugoslavia that the press were first actively targetted (you know one day I am going to charge you Andrea for this education you get everytime you try to argue with me). Now, the targetting of the press has reached a point that it never has before. The insurgents/islamists we’re fighting in Iraq see NO propaganda value in the reports in the Western media. Even the Serbs, when weighing it up thought it probably best not to attack western media if all else being equal. None of these limitations are in place in Iraq, with a journalist worth as much decapitated as reporting for Washpost NYT etc.
    Finally I know one of the people in that article, so have heard what’s it like. Sorry Andrea, but that trumps all what you read at LGF and Instapundit.
    See Andrea, if you know something, look how more fruitful one’s posts are.

  10. Franky Avatar
    Franky

    what’s funny in that article is the quote by the Fox news guy, you know that channel that has relentlessly criticised the war from the outset. Now they say its so dangerous they can’t travel. Those damned liberals “stabbing us in the back”.
    But if people sitting in farms in Idaho write on internet comments sections of blogs that in fact Iraq is really safe and it’s all a big liberal lie, well damnit, that’s good enough for me.

  11. David Broadus Avatar

    Can’t agree more. I have been reading Iraqi and Iranian Bloggers for over a year. Get it from the source, unfiltered.
    For the lastest in news and views, and more links than you can follow, check out All Things Political or my new Blog All Things Political for my rants on the news of the day.

  12. Andrea Harris Avatar

    Wow, Franky, you know me better than I know myself. You know what I’ve read, what I believe… why, you even know I live in Idaho! You sad clown, do you even know where Idaho is? Why do I get the feeling I’ve travelled to more countries than you have?

  13. Andrea Harris Avatar

    Angelos: !!!!

  14. Franky Avatar
    Franky

    Yeah right, Andrea. It’s that understanding and interest you show in the world beyond your desk that marks you out as a world traveller. Hey maybe you could begin a new trend: cosmopolitan hicks!!!!

  15. Andrea Harris Avatar

    “Cosmopolitan hick.” You can’t be serious. Is that really the best you can do, Franky wanky? Wow, the next thing you’ll be telling me I’m ugly and my mother dresses me funny.

  16. Jettison Avatar

    Gretta van sustran has one. http://www.foxnews.com/

  17. Mork Avatar

    Shouldn’t a responsible journalist verify the identity of his or her sources before quoting them?
    At least they know that the “man on the street” who they collar for a quote is actually there, and the random nature of the interaction reduces the possibility that they are a person with a particular agenda to advance.

  18. Jim Avatar

    There’s one HUGE reason why this will never happen: it will ruin the story “reporters” want to tell in order to advance their own political agendas…
    If you actually read the blogs, you get a far different picture of Iraq than what you get from “reporters.” Let’s see how difficult it is to figure this out….
    Somewhere around 90% of “reporters” vote Democratic and the drumbeat of coverage is overwhelmingly anti-Bush….
    Actual Iraqis report their generally positive experience and happiness with being liberated and they’re ignored or disparaged and the only “news that’s fit to print” out of Iraq concern the handful of trouble spots left to be cleaned out…
    I guess the 20-odd million Iraqis trying to get on with their lives and build a future somehow don’t exist…At least not if they don’t want to blow up Americans or bash the president while they do it…
    Does anyone, anywhere really doubt that the “reporting” would be vastly different were a Democratic president in charge? Can you say “Bos-ni-a”??? [Here’s your answer for those who can’t: When was the last story you read about what a mess we (and the Europeans) left there, the incompetence of the UN “peacekeepers,” and how many people are still dying there every day because Clinton tried to half-fight a war??]
    Do I really have to state what should be obvious to anyone with a pair of working brain cells?
    If Kerry wins in November, you can be sure that suddenly the press will discover positive stories in Iraq and the negative reporting will disappear overnight…Until then, keep holding your breath waiting for positive reporting from Iraq….

  19. R. Avatar

    “At least they know that the “man on the street” who they collar for a quote is actually there,”
    Did you even read the original post Mork? if these “journo’s” are too afraid to leave their hotel, how the hell do you propose they meet the “man on the street”?

  20. Mork Avatar

    R. – you need to relax a bit, fella. You’ll blow a gasket if you keep getting all riled up over nothing.
    All I was trying to do was illustrate the difficulty of relying on bloggers by comparing them to the technique journalists usually use to include “local perspective” in their stories.
    Stick to reading the actual words, OK?