From Iraq

From Iraq
: Zeyad has a pained and blunt view of the state of Iraq — and Iraqi leadership — after a year:

A whole year has passed now and I can’t help but feel that we are back at the starting point again. The sense of an impending disaster, the ominous silence, the breakdown of most governmental facilities, the absence of any police or security forces, contradicting news reports, rumours everywhere, and a complete disruption in the flow of everyday life chores.

All signs indicate that it’s all spiralling out of control, and any statements by CPA and US officials suggesting otherwise are blatantly absurd….

It is becoming increasingly evident from all the violence we have witnessed over the last year, that a proxy war is being waged against the US on Iraqi soil by several countries and powers with Iraqis as the fuel and the fire, just like Lebanon was during the late seventies and eighties. The majority of Arab regimes have a huge interest in this situation continuing, not to mention Iran, and Al-Qaeda. I am not trying, of course, to lift the blame from Iraqis, because if Iraqis were not so divided the way they are, these powers would have never succeeded. I never thought that Iraqis would be so self-destructive, I thought that they had enough of that. But with each new day I am more and more convinced that we need our own civil war to sort it all out. … If the ‘resistance’ succeeded and ‘liberated’ Iraq, the country would immediately be torn into 3, 4, 5 or more parts with each faction, militia, or army struggling to control Baghdad, Kirkuk, Najaf, Karbala, and the oil fields. It will not be a sectarian war as many would imagine, it would be a war between militias. We already have up to 5 official militias, not to mention the various religious groups and armies.

It is the most foolish and selfish thing to say “pull the troops out”, or “replace them with the UN or NATO”. Someone has to see us through this mess to the end. Only a deluded utopian (or an idiot peace activist) would believe that Iraqis would all cosily sit down and settle down their endless disputes without AK-47’s, RPG’s, or mortars in the event of coalition troops abandoning Iraq. Please please don’t get me wrong, I am not in the least saying that I enjoy being occupied by a foreign force, I am not a dreamer who believes that the USA is here for altruistic reasons, I am not saying that I am happy with what my bleeding country is going through, believe me when I say it tears my heart every day to witness all the bloodshed, it pains me immensely to see that we have no leaders whomsoever with the interest and well-being of Iraq as their primary goal, it kills me to see how blind and ignorant we have all become. Iraqis are dying inside every day, and we are committing suicide over and over and over. Some people call me a traitor or a collaborator for all the above and for speaking the truth as opposed to rhetorical, fiery speeches which have been our downfall.

He also says regarding the hostages:

I also received an incredible number of emails and appeals from Japanese citizens and organizations asking me to spare the lives of the Japanese hostages (do they think I have something to do with the kidnapping??) and to tell the ‘mujahideen’ that the hostages were all against the war (as if that would make any difference to the kidnappers).

: Nabil is a teenager who wanted to write about sports on his blog. Instead, he’s writing about living in the neighborhood of war:

Yesterday was a huge day it was full if fighting, full of bombing, full of dead people and was a scary day too.

When I waked up I saw the American soldiers blocked the streets and there were a big battle between the soldiers and fedayeen and as what the fedayeen said they destroyed four tanks and four humer and killed about three soldiers. It was a horrible day to me because (think about it) wake up in a middle of the fighting….

we thought that its over but suddenly a huge sound and a lot of bullets after from the American side and another one in about 20 minutes we all get in the house and we saw a big queue of a big tanks and a lot of American cars and soldiers the and the last car stopped facing my house I told every one in my house we all goanna die but the fedayeen when the saw the big queue they just stopped and leave the place and every thing now is alright but in 9 pm I was out of my house with my friends which they are my neighbor and another sounds of bombing and shooting we all gets inside our house and we didn’t leave our houses for all the day and I hope I will never see a day like this day.

: Omar just keeps blogging:

The strike -that the terrorists called for- didn’t take place the way they desired; I wandered a lot in Baghdad today and I can assume that more than 50% of the shopkeepersrefused to submit to the thugs’ threats but in A’adhamiya, the situation is different, almost all the shops are closed today as there were intense clashes between the fedayeen and the coalition troops, heavy gunfire and explosions were heard in the morning.

The traffic activity in Baghdad is normal and the whole city is quiet except A’adhamiya, even that Ali and I today met a journalist and a photographer from the (USA today). We spent more than 3 hours together during which we had a lot of conversation; we had lunch in a restaurant in Karrada and they made an interview with us about the Iraqi blogs. Later we all went to an internet cafe’ to show them more details about our blog work.

: Things clearly vary neighborhood by neighborhood. Firas had a good day.

: Faiza is angry.

:Raed apologizes to the people of Japan because of its hostages.

:Says Alaa:

I hope you all realize that a major objective of the enemy is to produce defeatism in the U.S. and allied nations home front, counting on the democratic process to force the hand of policy makers. The War in fact never stopped from the first day of the fall of the Icon….

One thing is fundamental though: Once you start exercising firmness it will be disastrous if you falter and show weakness again. Diplomacy and politics are essential of course, but the arguments of the strong are always much more convincing.

: To find out what’s happening in Iraq, Roger L. Simon is reading the Iraqi blogs instead of the L.A. Times.

: An American in Iran says the news in Iraq is getting less attention in Iran than she would have thought. And she’s relieved.

13 responses to “From Iraq”

  1. Otter Avatar

    As crucial as this is to the US, ultimately it’s the Iraqis who have to live with the consequences and who absolutely have to make this work. Easy for me to say as I don’t have to take the risks and I don’t even have the slightest idea what they *could* do, but at the end of the day it’s in their hands. I wish them luck.
    re Japan: I’ve lived and worked there, and while I love the country and people, it would be quicker to list what they *do* understand about other countries and societies than what they don’t.

  2. button Avatar

    I was ‘touring’ the Iraqi Blogs late last night and found it so painful that I had to finally quit and go to sleep because I just couldn’t take it anymore.
    Last, but not least, Salam Pax posted that he is taking a hiatus, but he didn’t say for how long.
    By the way, I believe, last I read from Faiza that Raed is in Amman for further post-grad studies, so he must be actually posting from there. I wish he would do a ‘dateline’ to clarify that.

  3. MattS Avatar

    This invasion was a great idea!

  4. Ebb Tide Avatar
    Ebb Tide

    Poor Zeyad, he is also posting crazy stuff like this:
    “There were many tales about M1A2 tanks having some sort of electromagnetic field (or something to that effect) surrounding it which protects it from RPG attacks. Someone said that the Fedayeen have overcome this problem by smearing the rockets with mud, after previous attempts in the past of wrapping them with cloths or nylon failed.”
    I am worried about Zeyad, he is losing it.

  5. Ebb Tide Avatar
    Ebb Tide

    Jeff, you forgot to link to Alaa’s blog:
    http://messopotamian.blogspot.com/

  6. Ga-ne-sha Avatar
    Ga-ne-sha

    We and the Iraqis have to go through this. Such a situation is a true crucible of formation, involving confrontation with actual forces, which produces meaning in life, character and understanding. Nothing is certain.
    In contrast, Liberals such as J.F.K. think meaning is produced from the safety of meetings with “consensus”, which then somehow magically causes the world to do the “right” thing. They always seek the comfort of fantasy — thinking makes it so — instead of the effort of real action which is painful and risky, extreme discomfort and death being a possibility.
    Therefore, second guessing is a way of life with these Liberals. The correct “plans” were not made in the meetings, since they were not there to make them. Yet they still have no plans, except more meetings. Has the U.N. yet had meetings to decide what “serious consequences” are if not what we are doing?
    Such Liberals are basically lazy cowards, appeasers, non-risk takers, who favor their little comfort zones, which are also fictions.

  7. CharlesWT Avatar
    CharlesWT

    “There were many tales about M1A2 tanks having some sort of electromagnetic field (or something to that effect) surrounding it which protects it from RPG attacks…”
    Smart Armor

  8. CharlesWT Avatar
    CharlesWT

    Perhaps Salam is taking some time off for some globe trotting…
    …next month’s Sydney Writers Festival…including…recent literary sensations

  9. button Avatar

    Good catches, CharlesWT! Thanks. I think I’ll save those.
    Maybe someone should establish a micro-fansite for him. At the very least Emigre at Iraqi Blog Count could probably post the info, but maybe Salam might feel shy about that.

  10. Faramin Avatar

    I think you “forgot” to mention this blog who also happens to be Iraqi, like Ziad and the ones you love to quote from.

  11. Swopa Avatar

    To find out what’s happening in Iraq, Roger L. Simon is reading the Iraqi blogs instead of the L.A. Times.
    Which, unfortunately, is part of why Roger is essentially clueless about what’s going on in Iraq.
    There’s enough Iraqi blogs now that it’s easy to find one whose opinions mirror your own — at which point many people (including Roger and Jeff, apparently) shout “Hurray! I don’t have to question my preconceived notions!” and shut their brains down.
    Obviously, this is a problem on other issues as well.

  12. lefty in canada Avatar

    Jeff and Roger have not shut their minds down, but perhaps they should also link to Tacitus, who is applying some seriously skeptical doubt to the whole Iraq campaign. If Robert Novak is tottering on the brink of calling for a return of the draft, then you had better read something other than the good blogs of Baghdad.
    Will this be the grim question in a fortnight: either a general mobilization of all reserves, or a general cut and run?

  13. Doctor Slack Avatar
    Doctor Slack

    Agree with Swopa about the usual consequences of cherry-picking of Iraqi blogs by Simon and others. (To be fair, Jeff is somewhat better on this score much of the time.)
    If there are going to be useful suggestions on what kind of actions to support in Iraq, folks like Simon aren’t likely to be their source. There’s a much more interesting attempt to grapple with the problem here (and counterpoints from Kevin Drum).