The echo meme

The echo meme
: I’m now sitting in an ad hoc press conference kind of thing with Tim O’Reilly and Rael Dornfest, the program head for ETech. As I walk in, they’re discussing the left-leaning echo chamber issue from yesterday’s Digital Democracy day (see posts below).

O’Reilly said that he sees absolutely no connection between this technology and the left. It will be used by all sides of all issues.

Doc Searls, who was on the conference committee, said they tried to find some conservatives to join in but had difficulty finding them.

O’Reilly conceded that conferences are put together by networks and this network of who-knows-whom happens to lean that way and thus finds those people.

Another member of the committee said that in talking to conservatives, they are “very happy with talk radio” and aren’t as deseparate for new things as the liberals, thus liberals are using this stuff more.

They dealt with it directly. That’s what’s great about both this world and O’Reilly himself: Openness and immediacy.

: Corrected. I thought Micah Sifry was there; I uncharacteristically took notes on this on paper and I have the world’s worst handwriting and the world’s second-worst memory (so I can’t remember who was there). Sorry.

4 responses to “The echo meme”

  1. Ken Layne Avatar

    Jarvis wrote: “Another member of the committee said that in talking to conservatives, they are ‘very happy with talk radio’ and aren’t as deseparate for new things as the liberals, thus liberals are using this stuff more.
    They dealt with it directly. That’s what’s great about both this world and O’Reilly himself: Openness and immediacy.”
    Really? That doesn’t sound great, open or immediate. That sounds like an idiotic, heavily predjudiced insult. Oh, you know *their* kind! They’re happy with the simple things. Loose shoes, fried chicken.
    Reality Update: FreeRepublic.com was organizing regular D.C. rallies (at SCOTUS, Congress, the White House) at least as far back as 1998. People organized on the Free Republic boards and came from all over the country for these things. I don’t know this from network news or the paper; I know it because I regularly walked around Freeper demonstrations to get to work at UPI next door to the White House. The rah-rah for the MeetUp / MoveOn stuff would be a bit more credible if it included some acknowledgement of similar innovations that preceded it by many years.
    Yeah, it’s *real* difficult to find a political conservative with a web log. Let’s see, just in California (and just off the top of my head) you’ve got the brilliant Eugene Volokh and all his libertarian / conservative co-bloggers, the hilarious and very conservative Cathy Seipp, the terrific right-leaning CalBlog, the hell-raising sci-fi writer / conservative blogger Bill Quick (Daily Pundit), etc. And if the conference organizers are only able to think of political conservatives as talk-radio performers, why didn’t they at least invite Hugh Hewitt?
    He would fit right into the stereotype, except he’s an enthusiastic & popular blogger … and a loyal citizen of Los Angeles … and a long-time television journalist & talk-show host for the PBS station in L.A.!
    I know & like several of the people at this conference (Copeland, Searls, Emmanuelle, maybe Matt, maybe even Jarvis!), but y’all are really guzzling the kool-aid if locking half the country out of these Huzzah 4 Hippies With Computerz conferences somehow translates to “Openness and immediacy.”

  2. Micah Sifry Avatar

    Ummm, much as it’s nice to my name mentioned (and spelled right!), I’m pretty sure I was just getting out of bed around the time of the events described…maybe it’s my body double you saw???

  3. Richard Bennett Avatar

    Two years ago at SXSW, Meg Hourihan and Doc Searls were whining about how conservatives dominated the blogosphere, and now they can’t find any?
    How quickly they change their tune.

  4. Ruby Sinreich Avatar

    Not to say that the Teach-In didn’t rock. (It did.) But another missing voice was that of people and organizations who are using online advocacy around non-tech issues. This gap was especially evident on the “Advocacy as Application” and “Political Plogging” panel, although if I was a journalist, I’d probably point it out on your Media panel as well.
    More about this @ my blog.