Protecting the masses

Protecting the masses
: While Michael Powell is trying to wash our media mouths out with soap — he wants to multiply by 10 the fines charged for dirty words on the air — Britain has its own nanny trying to protect their tender sensibilities.

Clare Short, disloyal opposition to Tony Blair, wants to ban breasts:

Ms Short criticised the Sun at a Westminster lunch yesterday, where she said she wanted to “take the pornography out of our press”.

“I’d love to ban it. It degrades women and our country,” she said.

“A survey of Sun readers’ wives and daughters showed they believed it degraded them. We need to push back the tide of nakedness. You can’t take it out of the whole of society but I think you can take it out of the mainstream,” she added.

And The Sun hit back. The paper sent a bevvy of Page 3 girls to Short’s house so they could put a picture of them at her door with the caption, “Door knockers” (no distance is too far to go for a punchline), and so they could quote one of them saying:

12 responses to “Protecting the masses”

  1. Theodopoulos Pherecydes Avatar
    Theodopoulos Pherecydes

    Why say “F the FCC”?
    Because you have good taste and a respect for community standards, that’s why.
    If it can be absolutely inappropriate and extremely rare for the word “nigger” to be used in public/print, why cannot the same argument be raised for a “dirty dozen” or however many words are deemed inappapropriate at the dinner table?
    I don’t see why there shouldn’t be debate and national legislation on what constitutes the FCC “community” and its standards. The debate would certainly be worth the price of admission.

  2. Hipocrite Avatar
    Hipocrite

    Who watches the watchemen?

  3. Anonymous Avatar
    Anonymous

    watchmen, even.

  4. Easycure Avatar

    Jeff, I’m with you. If we represent the land of the free, we should fe free to say fcuk whenever, wherever, and to whoever.

  5. Susan Avatar

    The entertainment industry has already indoctrinated the masses to idea that “F..k” everything is an acceptable way to speak. It really is just too cool, you know, to f..king say f..k. So shut the f..k up you f..king righteous f..kheads at the FCC who want to f..king tell me what the f..k I can or can not say.
    Today’s modern language has advanced itself backwards.
    Theodopoulous, perhaps what you really meant to say is that it is not acceptable for a caucasian to use the “n…er” word, however, everyone else is free to do so, as exhibited in the lyrics found in rap music.
    Of course, the entertainment industry claims all this is for “artistic” purposes and is perfectly acceptable because it lacks good taste and has no respect for community standards.

  6. Mike Avatar

    Am I missing something here? Didn’t you just mention that you edit this blog for unseemly language since your kids may read it? Isn’t it a bit hypocritical to argue for completely unfettered speech? I can cuss with the best but I surely strive not to do it in front of children or anyone else I know will be offended.

  7. Jeff Jarvis Avatar

    Mike: I’d rather that be my choice than the government’s. And it will be the market’s choice. Radio and TV that use it will lose certain audience and advertisers; magazines that use it may get kicked out of Walmart. I trust the authors and the audience more than I trust the government. I’m an absolutist on free speech.

  8. Mike Avatar

    Jeff: Fair enough. Would you also extend free market regulation to tobacco, alcohol, drugs, prostitution, etc.? I personally wish that a libertarian approach would work, but I’m doubtful.

  9. Kathy K Avatar

    I’d like The Sun better if they showed men too. Equal time, gents, equal time. We like to look too, yanno?
    Page 3 doesn’t offend me in the least. I just wish they’d expand it. ;)

  10. Rob Read Avatar

    Kathy,
    It was tried and failed was called page 7. Women like powerful &| rich men, not naked men.
    Since The Sun is the biggest selling newspaper and has a right of center viewpoint I’m sure the statists would love to censor others choices out of existence…
    The road to serfdom is paved with good intentions!

  11. Andrew | BYTE BACK Avatar

    So it’s not man boobs right?

  12. Dave F Avatar

    “We must turn back the tide of nakedness” is absolutely wonderful. It is very hard to believe Clae Short actually said that. I imagine the phrase will haunt her to the end of her political days. It may even be her footnote to history.