Yeah, and Charles Manson said he was God

Yeah, and Charles Manson said he was God
: I have a bone to pick with today’s New York Times front page. It presents the words of Saddam Hussein in his interrogation as if they had any possible credibility. Says the head:

Hussein Tells Interrogators

He didn’t Direct Insurgency

Also Denies That Iraq Possessed Illicit Weapons

Well, put that next to a picture of the vermin-infested, crazy-eyed, pathologically lying mass murdered, willya?

A little perspective, please. This is treated as if what he says is news for its own sake. Oh, it’s news — but more as gossip, as the rantings of the sleep- and soap-starved lunatic leader.

Five graphs down, the Times does say that “intelligence and military officials still said they were discounting much of the little information that Mr. Hussein had offered so far.” But that’s not good enough. That’s a big “of course!”

The story and headline are simply written the wrong way. It should be more of a view of what’s happening in this interrogation and what lunacy he’s spewing, not as quotes from a credible national leaders.

Newspapers all have a problem dealing with lunatics; in print, the quotes of saints and madmen all come out in black-and-white. Sometimes, it is necessary to put a little color around that. Even saying, “After the deposed leader was deloused, he said…” would help.

8 responses to “Yeah, and Charles Manson said he was God”

  1. James Avatar

    The NYT also reported that the captive Saddam told a member of the Iraqi Governing Council that he didn’t launch a WMD attack on Halabja, because after all, he says, *the Iranians did it*. Also, that the mass graves only contain traitors and criminals. Well hell, then it must be true. OUR MISTAKE, LET HIM GO.
    Now the NYT’s site is running the report of this new ambush that left 12 insurgents and 0 coalition soldiers dead, and that this “appeared to be a further sign that the insurgency has not slowed”. Maybe, but an equally valid interpretation is that the insurgency has no more strategic command, no more high-tech weaponry, and is desperately, futilely lashing out. Especially with, you know, the 12-0 score and THE FLOCK OF PIGEONS as a signaling device.

  2. Maciej Ceglowski Avatar

    I think the facts pretty clearly show that Saddam Hussein, whatever else he is, was not a lunatic. His ability to survive twenty years of various attempts on his life and seven months of an intensive manhunt, while dismaying, is hardly consistent with his being out of his gourd.
    There’s a temptation to call these evil, self-aggrandizing narcissist dictators crazy. But I think that’s just a cop-out – an evasion out of the wider problem of evil.
    There’s a good article on the topic by Stephen Humphreys – The Myth of the Middle East Madman.
    That business aside, Jeff’s point about Hussein’s veracity and credibility is well taken.

  3. cridland Avatar

    “Newspapers all have a problem dealing with lunatics; in print, the quotes of saints and madmen all come out in black-and-white.”
    In ’96 or so, Newsweek put a picture of McVeigh on the cover with the headline “The Suspect Speaks!”
    As if all the world had been waiting for this man to reveal our truths. The pomposity did not diminish the sadness I felt for the victim’s families, whose tradgedy was exploited for abject profits.

  4. Andrew | BYTE BACK Avatar

    i thought you were busy? What’s with this lame swipe at the NY Times headline?

  5. Angus Jung Avatar
    Angus Jung

    Andrew’s right. I demand a refund!

  6. Steve in Houston Avatar
    Steve in Houston

    It’d be nice to get the same kind of quotes we see around, say, Reuters’ treatment of “terrorists”.
    More than anything, people like Saddam are serial killers writ large. Follow-up interviews with these guys all show the same thing: Lack of remorse, responsibility or sense of shared humanity, and an overwhelming self-regard. The pathologies are similar, the only real differences are those of scale.

  7. Mithras Avatar

    Hussein Tells Interrogators
    He Directed Insurgency
    Also Admits That Iraq Possessed Illicit Weapons
    Then what would Jarvis’s reaction be? He wouldn’t be skeptical, that’s for sure.

  8. DakRoland Avatar

    I’m still amazed no one has jumped on this little news kernel….
    http://www.foxnews.com/story/0,2933,105895,00.html
    Associated Press
    Tuesday, December 16, 2003
    WASHINGTON