Le Carre’s screed

Le Carre’s screed
: John le Carre’s new novel is about out and the Observer goes gaga over this too-timely screed in the book:

‘That war on Iraq was illegitimate… it was a criminal and immoral conspiracy. No provocation, no link with al-Qaeda, no weapons of Armageddon. Tales of complicity and Osama were self-serving bullshit. It was an old colonial war dressed up as a crusade for Western life and liberty, and it was launched by a clique of war-hungry Judaeo-Christian geopolitical fantasists who hijacked the media and exploited America’s post-Nine Eleven psychopathy.’

Colonial war? No, mate, you should know better: That assumes we want to move into Iraq. That was how you Brits ran the world. We want only to get back home (if too soon).

When he wrote about Communism and the cold war, le Carre understood and expressed the subtlety of it. Judging from this there’s no subtlety left in his weltanschauung or his writing.

18 responses to “Le Carre’s screed”

  1. Average Joe Avatar
    Average Joe

    Well come on, the guy’s got a French pen name. What did you expect?

  2. daudder Avatar

    That’s a pen name…

  3. Average Joe Avatar
    Average Joe

    Didn’t I say that?

  4. Yehudit Avatar

    Such a shame. I used to love his books. Now he’s turned into an elderly crank.

  5. Oliver Avatar

    No, its not American colonization. Its corporate. All those great deals for campaign contributors… what a bargain, just a few soldier’s lives (and none of ’em with enough money to qualify as “Pioneer” contributors, so eff em).

  6. Peace Creep Avatar
    Peace Creep

    Oliver, you forgot to mention BUSH LIED!!!! and NO BLOOD FOR OIL!!!!!!!!!!!

  7. Jeremy Avatar

    Shouldn’t you be out raising money for Saddam, Oliver?

  8. Mithras Avatar

    When he wrote about Communism and the cold war, le Carre understood and expressed the subtlety of it.
    Did you ever actually read any of his books? Russia House, for example? Masterful book, all about the Soviet Union; his best, I think. America doesn’t come off too well in that one, either. Or most of his others: Night Manager, Secret Pilgrim, Honourable Schoolboy. Actually, he’s criticized US government and US society pretty much his whole career.

  9. Jeff Jarvis Avatar

    Mithras: Of course, I read those books. In all of them, everybody was vaguely venal. Nothing was ever stated as baldly as in that one quoted paragraph. My point is more about style than politics. LeCarre used to be subtle; now he’s throwing brickbats. He might as well be Clancy then.

  10. Glenn Avatar

    The trouble with writing books in this day and age is that the news keeps coming every day. One wouldn’t want to look like a fool. Well, I guess some don’t notice and some just don’t care.
    I have Le Carre’s book, The Russia House, sitting on my bookshelf. i wonder if I’ll ever bother picking it up.

  11. Oliver Avatar

    You right-wingers would be hilarious paradoies if you weren’t serious. Sad.

  12. Unemployed Jerk Avatar
    Unemployed Jerk

    Oliver,
    As long as you and people like you continue calling liberals (yes, I’m a liberal) “right-wingers” for supporting the overthrow of a fascist dictator, you can expect to lose a lot of elections.
    Sad.

  13. Fred Avatar

    I have just re-read some of Cornwell’s older books. I first read him before Reagan knocked over the Berlin wall and demonstrated the lack of clothing of the soviet king.
    Cornwell was always a foolish man. He clearly believed in the moral equivalence of the west and the soviet union. He believed the soviet union had the economy they claimed and would eventually out produce the west. In retrospect, little he said makes much sense today.
    We need to be careful of many older men. They were successfully propagandized as young men and still believe much of the old socialist claptrap.

  14. JorgXMcKie Avatar
    JorgXMcKie

    Unemployed jerk: You evidently have never run into this (apocraphyl) French quote: “Of course it works in practice, but what about *theory*?” Oliver and such others care very little about what actually happens in the real world and very much about what should or would happen in a theoretical world. Unfortunately, we have to live in the practical, real world. Thus, liberals who oppose real, actual inhumanity are called “right-wingers” by leftist ideologues. It will make you a very uncomfortable bedfellow if you try to join them while keeping your view in the real world.

  15. Mithras Avatar

    Fred-
    He clearly believed in the moral equivalence of the west and the soviet union. He believed the soviet union had the economy they claimed and would eventually out produce the west.
    On what do you base this? He certainly seemed to consider the officers of western and Soviet intelligence services to be morally equivalent. As for the rest, he was clearly disappointed that the Soviets were thugs and tyrants, when the Russians had tried so hard to pull their society out of the Csarist muck. All along though, he was clear that they were thugs and tyrants, as a group. Of course, he could treat individual Russians as people, not as stereotypes.
    Jarvis – I read those books. In all of them, everybody was vaguely venal. Nothing was ever stated as baldly as in that one quoted paragraph.
    The entire plot of Honourable Schoolboy (1977) turns on a CIA betrayal of the Brits, in which they conspire with drug dealers and precipitate the murder of a heroic British agent. True, there isn’t a single paragraph of such force as the one you quote in his work pre-Russia House. But if he is being strident, it might be because he’s unusually provoked.

  16. old spook Avatar
    old spook

    Cornwell was a SIS officer targeting the Soviet Union. He knew and was friends with many of the those who spied for the KGB in the late 50s, early 60s. Partly from CIA pressure he, and others were forced out from 1963 to 69. Given the depth of Soviet penetration of the SIS and MI-5 there really was no choice. And yes, according to those who knew, and worked with him, he hates americans, and what he thinks america stands for. A fuller record of “Mr. Box” will have to wait till after he leaves this earth.(All of this is on the public record, you have to dig a little.)

  17. Jack Tanner Avatar
    Jack Tanner

    ‘No, its not American colonization. Its corporate. All those great deals for campaign contributors’
    There’s an original thought. When that one doesn’t work go back to worldwide hegemony.

  18. eileen Avatar

    Surely you jest! Le Carre is still in top form. Just because some of you may be feeling patriotic in an ersatz way, does not mean that Le Carre/Cornwell is mistaken. ALthough I agree that “colonial war” may not be the right term for it, it surely is a misbegotten one; and all the smiley-faced, rah-rah pronouncements from the prexy and his ill-advising ilk will not change the fact of that. Sigh! What a sad, sad waste!