The new Holocaust deniers of 9/11

spiegel0903.jpgThe new Holocaust deniers of 9/11

: There’s a most disturbing trend in European media: giving attention — and thus credence — to the conspiracy crackpots, the moral equivalent of Holocaust deniers, who are trying to argue that 9/11 was not a terrorist attack but was, instead, some gigantic plot by the U.S. government, the Israeli government, the British government, and whoever else Europeans happen to dislike these days.

It’s sick enough that these people exist. It’s sicker still that they write books that get bought. It’s sick beyond tolerance that once-credible media outlets give them attention.

: The latest: Der Spiegel’s cover story this week puts the burning Twin Towers on their head with a cover story that asks: “Were the attacks on New York and Washington the biggest act of terrorism in history — or a gigantic plot by the secret services? Conspiracy theorists are writing bestsellers with their alleged evidence, and already a fifth of Germans believe their half-truths.”

As Eamonn Fitzgerald points out, this is a most cynical act: The editors of Der Spiegel cloak their story in doubt — but if there’s so much doubt, why is this a story, why is it a long story (14 pages of solid text on my printout), and why is it a cover story?

I couldn’t bear to translate the whole thing but from what I read, it’s enough to make me suggest that we all buy European tinfoil futures. Fitzgerald has more about the list of “authors” the magazine promotes:

And as Der Spiegel doesn’t want to be left behind in this race to the bottom, it joins a growing list of charlatans doing a steady business pawning their fabrications to a credulous public. Leading the field is Thierry Meyssan, the crackpot French author of The Horrifying Fraud, which posits that a missile fired by the military itself hit the Pentagon on 9/11. His horrifying, but successful, fraud was the inspiration for Mathias Br

21 responses to “The new Holocaust deniers of 9/11”

  1. David Kaspar Avatar

    While I agree that the SPIEGEL sometimes can be openly antiamerican – and in particular anti-Bush – I don’t see their latest output
    http://www.spiegel.de/archiv/dossiers/0,1518,259294,00.html
    lending credibility to conspiracy theories re 9-11. They more or less call conspiracy theorists lunatics.
    I haven’t read the new issue, though.

  2. BigFire Avatar

    Jeff, you don’t have to wait for Oliver Stone conspiracy minded movie. Michael Moore will be doing that as his next fictional documentary film.

  3. button Avatar

    I commented on this at the thread below “tinfoil hat army.” My comment probably should have gone here. We need to think about our response to this. We cannot control other people, but we can control how we deal with them.

  4. Lord Xenu Avatar

    Americans go to church. Europeans sneer at religion but still feel the need to “believe” in something.

  5. JanH Avatar

    Very interesting! I have spent the weekend debunking the details in Michael Meacher’s conspiracy theories in my blog, and this was useful inforomation about how these crazy stories are getting popular here in Europe.
    The dolkestoss legend of our times!

  6. sam Avatar

    the disturbing part isn’t the bull passed for nonfiction, the Euros have long had a taste for that. This is more than that. This is Europe waking up to the fact they aren’t important any more. That’s a big blow to their egos, but it is also making them afraid. They have not put money in to the armies. They have no significant level of defense. That’s why the ‘US is trying to take over the world’ theory is suddenly so popular. And it is sudden. Most of this has grown up since we ran over Iraq. We were not only exspected to fail, Russia was already claiming a share of the criet for our pending defeat. You may have seen the comments in Russain newspapers about Russian Generals visiting Iraq just before the war. They were ready to crow when we failed. That we succeeded and so swiftly was a double shock. Europe’s reaction has been surpriseingly irrasional. There is the danger this stuff isn’t just a trend. The Europeans have a long history of killing the things they fear.

  7. Seb Avatar

    I think that if you did read the whole article, you would find that it doesn’t say what you think it does. I posted some comments here.

  8. J Bradley Johnson Avatar
    J Bradley Johnson

    That there was a “conspiracy” can’t be doubted; the events of 9/11 didn’t happen without some planning by someone. The question that you have to answer, after looking at the evidence, is this: was there a conspiracy between a bunch of guys in caves in Afghanistan behind the terrorism? Or could it have been something more… sophisticated?

  9. Myles Avatar

    Listen to yourselves. Fools.

  10. Myles. Avatar

    Sorry. Can you delete that Jeff.

  11. Ryan Avatar

    It’s ‘labour’. I know it’s ‘labor’ in American spelling, but when you are referring to the proper noun for the British labour party you spell it ‘labour’.

  12. john b Avatar

    Whatever your views on the 9/11 conspiracy theorists, it’s offensive and stupid to liken them to holocaust deniers. It puts you in the same bracket as the embarrassing kids on the left who say “Bush = Hitler”. Or the tinfoil-behatted loon above who compares 9/11 to the Reichstag fire.
    9/11 was horrible. The holocaust was -beyond- horrible. They’re not comparable.

  13. Bob71 Avatar

    Along with antisemitism, it now seems that transference is a key indicator of the world’s willful losers. It’s not very far from “Bush = Hitler” to ‘9/11 = Reichstag fire.’
    After seeing the political banners for the extreme right Republicaner party on the drive in to Berlin (their slogan could be adapted for use by MEChA) it occured to me that the ban on Nazi-era images in Germany enables denial, thus making a repeat more likely rather than less.

  14. Alexander Avatar

    If you’re interested in the actual contents of the Spiegel article — instead of believing that the magazines promotes the conspiracy authors — have a look at Spiegel and 9/11: Beyond the buzz.

  15. M. Simon Avatar

    23 is really a cover for 93. XOR them together and what do you get? 74 or 1001010 binary. Of course that leads to only one conclusion. Consult Jimi Hendrix on number theory.
    Remember 3 is company but 23 is a crowd.
    I will say no more. Or less.

  16. raj Avatar

    “The editors of Der Spiegel cloak their story in doubt — but if there’s so much doubt, why is this a story, why is it a long story (14 pages of solid text on my printout), and why is it a cover story?”
    Why is it a cover story? This is a dumb question. Because it sells magazines. Spiegel has beat the regular news story to death over the last couple of years, and this article on conspiracy theorists is another angle that they can use to try to sell more magazines.

  17. Randal Robinson Avatar

    Jeff is right for smacking the Guardian around for providing a platform for this tinfoil nonsense but I think he missed the ball by lumping the Der Spiegel article into the same category. Apparently it’s an attack on these conspiracy theories, not something that gives them credence.
    When a poll reveals that almost one in three Germans below the age of 30 believe the U.S. government may have sponsored the 9/11 attacks then it appears that the lies, disinformation, and half-truths have spread too widely for the German major media to ignore.

  18. markus Avatar

    Jeff may be right when it comes to the Guardian, but he’s an ignorant twat who could use some reading classes when it comes to the Spiegel.
    The article in question is a brutal fisking of conspiracy terrorists, calling them crazy, forgers, liars and idiots and backing it all up with solid research.
    Only among similar idiots (and maybe thr reading-impaired) does this amount to “promoting” them, “pander[ing] to prejudices and suspicions that have no basis in fact.”
    Concerning the poll, it was two questions only, the first question raised doubts about the media coverage, and the second worded deliberately to get a juicy result. Saddly, the Zeit is responsible for that head-fart. More here: http://brmic.blogspot.com/2003_07_20_brmic_archive.html#105903902626051528
    (scroll down to “It’s possible Bush was behind 9-11”)

  19. jared Avatar

    wouldn’t it be a good idea to retract the piece about the spiegel in the blog? it’n nice that it’s been corrected in the comments. but who reads comments?

  20. Jeff Jarvis Avatar

    See my new post, above.