Thanks be to Rudy

Thanks be to Rudy
: John Podhoretz says that we can still thank Rudy Guliani for the fact that New York was calm and civilized and even good-hearted through the blackout.

What’s happening right now is a mere inconvenience compared to the world-changing horror of 9/11, but the wondrous spirit of New York that emerged from that catastrophe is still very much in evidence nearly two years later. Maybe that’s because we’ve been through that hell and we really do know the difference.

And once again, the city should recognize and acknowledge its enormous debt to the one man who really made it possible for us to weather these storms: Rudy Giuliani.

: The New York Times has a daintier — more sociological, less political — view of the same story.

But the reasons are also writ small, in commonplaces of New York life that would have been unthinkable in 1977. For one thing, you can smell the roses, or at least the city parks’ more varied assortment of flowers.

In innumerable locations they sprout unencumbered by the chicken wire that used to protect them from flower thieves, when they were grown at all.

: Not everybody was civlized all the time, of course. Everything’s relative. On the Real pay service, I saw a clip from CNN of a reporter using a payphone being harrassed by an angry mob wanting, understandably, to use the same phone. They hung it up on her.

It’s still New York.

: By the way, Maureen Dowd has lost it. I know that’s old news. But she wrote an OK column or two during 9.11 and the anthrax attacks. Those were the last she wrote. I thought she’d be able to tackle the blackout with at least a feature-writer’s flair, but instead she recycles old news in the cause of her tortured, lame, crippled, gimpy gags:

Steamed Iraqis offered us tips, including: Sleep on the roof and take showers. As in showdenfreude?

4 responses to “Thanks be to Rudy”

  1. joy Avatar

    About that mob, I think they’re in the right this time. I mean, how many of them had a cellphone that wasn’t functioning and higher priorities like kids, spouses and other family members waiting for them to get in touch?
    As opposed to some CNN reporter–who probably should have better communications equipment–was babbling about how it appeared to be controlled chaos?
    Just something to think about.

  2. John Avatar

    I think the change comes down to both a different sensability post-9/11, and an increased police presence, the latter of which Giuliani can take credit for improving.
    The people who would be most likely to take advantage of a blackout won’t if they fear the odds of getting arrested — or even worse, shot — are too great. New York’s problems between 1965 and 1977, which included the major budget cuts after the brush with bankruptcy and the deterioration of city services (even the subway graffiti indicated that no one either cared or was in charge), just were an open invitation for looting to occur.
    But at the same time, after the WTC attack, even your likely rioters today have to take pause when the power goes out, and think if this isn’t some new, and possibly even worse, terror secnario being played out. That takes away some of the “What’s in it for me?” mindset that leads people to start breaking windows or starting fires the moment problems begin, and 9/11 was so serious, that mentallity carries past the borders of New York and into other major cities like Cleveland and Detroit.

  3. Patrick Avatar

    I think it is important to look to larger explanations. Detroit was without power also, and is historically capable of rioting with the best of them. I think there is generally a different national attitude. And despite the changes that still need to be made, I think even the most disaffected and disenfranchised groups feel they have more of a stake in “the system” then they did 20 or 30 years ago.

  4. ken Avatar

    I haven’t bought a print issue of the Times in I don’t know how long. Haven’t read Dowd (except for her Fiskings) in forever. But Sunday, after a few days with no news, I felt I could handle the Times. I did. But the Dowd column. Geez. I can think of about 50 bloggers and 5,000 people who only write Christmas cards once a year who could write better than she does.
    I thought I was reading some 16-year-old’s column in the high school paper.
    The Times should be embarrassed.