The Baghdad Blog Times

The Baghdad Blog Times
: We webloggers should help Iraqis start weblog newspapers.

Iraq has had no free press, let alone freedom, for generations.

Weblogs give them the chance to publish freely, overnight, with no expense of printing presses and paper, no production equipment needed, no distribution network needed, no investment at all.

The beauty of weblogging is that it is the world’s cheapest — no, history’s cheapest — means of publishing. Weblogging brings the power of the press down to the people. And these people need it.

Of course, the audience in Iraq would be small at the start: tiny.

But the audience who can connect in Iraq and the audience elsewhere in the world who read this would be influential. Thus Iraqis would gain a voice in their country and in the world.

And this instant free press would exercise muscles of expression that have atrophied in Iraq. It would teach them how to report and comment and how to find the truth from beyond their borders.

When Eastern European countries were freed, Western newspaper journalists rushed there to teach them how to be journalists and how to publish. But those countries had an infrastructure of expression that does not exist in Iraq. And, besides, times have changed:

The web and weblogging have lowered the barrier to free expression.

I’ve been driving myself nuts trying to find a story I read a few weeks ago about a web-only newspaper in South Korea that is gaining more influence than the printed perss (can anybody send me that link?). That is a model for what can be accomplished in Iraq. Salam Pax is a model, too: He’s just one man who told the stories from inside Baghdad that were not being told. Hell, Josh Marshall keeping the Trent Lott story alive is a model, too, for it proved that one tenacious reporter can influence the national debate.

So what would we have to do? Not very damned much. Maybe nothing.

I’d be happy to exchange emails with any Iraqis who can speak English and who wants to start weblog, giving them instruction in how to make it happen. If this clicks and grows, we can help fund hosting for them. We can provide compelling design. We can shine the spotlight of the world on them. Or we can just watch. With so very little, the people of Iraq can gain a free press.

Imagine how that will change the world.

22 responses to “The Baghdad Blog Times”

  1. vasili Avatar

    what a dumb idea…

  2. Gray Avatar

    Jeff, what a crazy proposition? Maybe for the first you would be happy to help them restore phone stations destroyed by the US bombings?
    Or, maybe, for the first it would be better to establish law and order, stop the marauding acts in Baghdad and other cities?
    Or it is not necessary already? There is a new target – Syriah, it can cover Saddam, it can develop WMD`s, it can poses a threat to the USA, wait a minute, – they must have a link with al-Queda, because without this link the US cannot justify its will to invade a new colony…

  3. Pithpott Avatar
    Pithpott

    It won’t work! Although the newly democratic people all now have free computers, they have also exercised their right to use them as best suits their culture. The computer towers are preferred as ornate ashtray stands, alongside their also-looted armchairs.

  4. tom scott Avatar

    I think there is much merit in what you say. Your proposal is shapeless enough at this point to remain flexible. I like the idea and do not understand the negativity of the other commenters.

  5. stageleft Avatar

    Oddly enough I agree with you Jeff, I think that there should be free and uncensored blogging from Iraq – it would certainly give CNN a run for its money in the truth department.

  6. Pithpott Avatar
    Pithpott

    And precisely how long do you think any new authority in that region would permit “uncensored blogging”? How naive in any event, to believe an irate swell of apathetic global bloggers will rise up to re-liberate the inevitable re-repression of Iraqis.
    And with what? Increasingly viscious e-mails?
    “Oddly enough” is apt.

  7. Steve Hall Avatar

    Optimism, people. Optimism. Why are so many of you down on the possible upside of this idea? Sure, the infrastructure is beat to crap and maybe 2 people have internet access but I don’t think Jeff was suggesting that we put blogging as our first post-war Iraq reconstruction policy. It’s an idea…let it breath.

  8. Pithpott Avatar
    Pithpott

    If that culture had any history or intellectual intent of letting any fresh idea whatsoever breathe, I would prefer to join in with your huge intake of hope, Steve.
    Fact is, mankind doesn’t have enough time left on this earth to allow your optimism to bear fruit in that neck of the woods.

  9. Alan Burge Avatar
    Alan Burge

    Great idea! I wonder if Muhammad@aol.com is taken?

  10. tom scott Avatar

    Pithpot, urine my thoughts.
    This line threw me:“irate swell of apathetic global bloggers”
    Irate swell conjures up an emotional crowd while apathetic suggests an emotionless group. So are they irate or are they apathetic?

  11. Lutero Avatar

    I applaud any idea that encourages the education and empowerment of an oppressed community, whether it is 2 weeks, 2 years, or 2 decades in the making.

  12. Janis Gore Avatar
    Janis Gore

    Some of these comments sound awfully damned condescending to the Iraqis.

  13. Pithpott Avatar
    Pithpott

    Tom, consider yourself thrown, there are already too many people going around here stirring up apathy, making me urinate and all irate.
    Lutero, try applauding for 2,000 years and,
    Janis, they may sound condescending to the Iraqis, but they don’t to civilzed people. And judging by your surname you should know a thing or two about the subject.

  14. Janis Gore Avatar
    Janis Gore

    Well, Mith Pithy, you flamed that out. I think it’s a good idea, Mr. Jarvis.

  15. Jeff Jarvis Avatar

    Well I see we’ve gotten to the true feelings of valili/gray/pithpot (german/russian/canadian, by the way): They apparently don’t think the Iraqis were worth liberating since they have no faith that this free people can exercise their free speech and build a free press. Is that why you opposed this war, boys?
    I take my populist faith in the people — when the people are given a chance to govern themselves — seriously and I extend that faith beyond America to, yes, Iraq. These people deserve to be free. They deserved to be freed. They deserve a free press.
    If you think they deserve any less than that, then you are condescending to them.

  16. Pithpott Avatar
    Pithpott

    Thurley you pulleth my pither Jeff!
    I am fur the war, but only to bomb the buggers into getting rid of them weapons. I don’t give a rat’s bollock for their liberation, they don’t want it and have no inert desire to embrace it. And never will. With the weapons gone, why waste any more democratic lives? Are you a sadist?
    We can always revisit every ten years or so to remove their next build up. Frankly, I think they enjoy it, they seem a lot happier these days, running free and looting at will.

  17. Andrew | BYTE BACK Avatar

    I thought the post itself sounded kinda condescending, as if their democracy needed help from bloggers. As if they needed literacy lessons from bloggers [I hope everybody appreciates the humor there] Or that it is the “cheapest” form of publication.
    However, if *you* are talking potential global reach, I think there would be quite an audience for voices from Iraq – if they were in English of course. “Where’s Raed” is just one example.
    And there’s the first mistake. Iraqis who know English enough to write it and speak it – are they really that representative? I fail to see the connection on how bloggers could help Iraqi bloggers unless it’s with just pure promotion and being an audience – which cannot be discounted. Nothing about it would be the same as Western journalists heading over to Eastern European countries to advise on how to start a newspaper. Unless I’m missing something, which is entirely possible.
    Jeff Jarvis second post on this subject, instantly castigating those who don’t like the idea isn’t a good sign, however. There were 15 comments from about five people, three of whom didn’t like the idea. That’s called Jarvis reactionism – his right, of course.
    In summary, I’d like to read some more Iraqi POVs. But I believe that will come without help from bloggers. Anyway [to add new information and break the rules of a good summary] aren’t blogspot/blogger and google in the best place to help?

  18. button Avatar

    We were starting to get more POV’s just as things went down the tubes. Originally, Salam conceived the blog to be an ongoing ‘dialogue’ with his and Raed’s entries as the ‘letters.’ But Raed refused to participate. Then, before Salam went on ‘hiatus,’ some more folks started showing up.
    The Blogger and Google people have been helping. But I think we’re going to have an access problem before there will be more Iraqi Bloggers. I have to wonder how those Persians are managing to blog in terms of access. I don’t know what their access situation is.

  19. vasili Avatar

    jeff,
    it’s really amazing how you can judge from a short statement as it reads “what a dumb idea”, that i don’t think the iraqis were worth liberating or not able to excercise free speech.
    they might well be able to do anything they need to do. just give them food, water, medicine, electricity, jobs, houses, education – a future. that’s what they need now. on this list of things that the world should provide to this people (or at least should help them to get it on their own), a computer and a modem is surely not on top.
    that’s why your idea is dumb. come back with it in about a decade.

  20. button Avatar

    A decade??? You’re not being realistic. They have relatives in the US and elsewhere outside the country who want to be able to communicate with them. Nobody’s going to wait a decade. Not these days!

  21. Swerdloff Avatar

    It’s a great idea. Logistics will be difficult, of course, although slashdot ran a piece the other day on how geeks can help rebuild Iraq. They have the vaunted “.IQ” domain. http://slashdot.org/article.pl?sid=03/04/10/1558205&mode=thread&tid=95
    It’s not a magic bullet, but it’s a fine start. It also humanizes the people of Iraq. Which would be great. Not that blogging is a panacea, but giving people the ability to talk to each other and us is an excellent, and as you point out, very inexpensive, idea.

  22. mbaranow Avatar
    mbaranow

    i disagree about the claim that web-blogging is the histoy’s most inexpensive way of publishing news. it is quite the opposite.
    consider the cost of the necessary computer hardware, computer network infrastructure, not to mention the electricity needed to run all of this. each person who wants to read your blog from iraq needs a generator, can of kerosene, satelite phone, and modem, a industrial strenght casing laptop, and some bodyguards to prevent it from being stolen.
    webblogging is a fine way of publishing news for a wealthy and secure society. unless of course you open up a starbuck in baghdad…