Arch: So McDonald’s is in

Arch
: So McDonald’s is in trouble.

No surprise.

They haven’t been paying attention to their customers. They haven’t been keeping up with trends. They haven’t paid attention to details. They have done some dumb things.

A few months ago, amid huge hype and magillions of dollars of marketing, McDonald’s introduced a new chicken flatbread sandwich. It was good. It was so good, I started going to McDonald’s again. My wife, a McDonald’s hater, even liked it. The thing sold like crazy — even sold out in the first weeks. Life was good. I could eat fast food again and not feel as if I’d just subtracted another month from my already-too-short life.

But recently, out of nowhere, McDonald’s dropped the item.

So they wasted magillions of dollars of marketing and product development. They pissed off new customers. They showed themselves to have no clear strategy. They lost sight of the trend for freshness and against frying in American food. They screwed up. No wonder they are in trouble.

: Many years ago, when I was a columnist in San Francisco, McDonald’s opened a huge and very fancy restaurant over on Van Ness and I reviewed it (an idea you see all the time these days; then, I swear, it was slightly fresher). I had complaints about the place and immediately my bosses got a letter from Ray Kroc himself, complaining that I was a “codfish aristocrat” (that is, a snob without portfolio or bank account).

I called Kroc. I explained that, back in those days, I was a fan of McDonald’s. I ate there up to five times a week (sad, I know). I loved McDonald’s. But Mr. Kroc, I said, this restaurant just was not up to standards. They aren’t following your creed of Quality Control, I said. He begged me for details. He thanked me. We ended up friendly. And the restaurant got better.

Ray Kroc paid attention to the customer. He paid attention to details. He paid attention to the world around him.

When a company stops doing that, the company will fail.

No surprise.

2 responses to “Arch: So McDonald’s is in”

  1. Matt Welch Avatar

    Liked the analysis, hated that flatbread sandwich. You’ll want to replace the word “give” with “five.”
    In Europe, McDonald’s is far more sensitive to adapting to local tastes (and flattering local stereotypes), and makes a much bigger deal about opening more clean & beautiful locations than you’re used to seeing there (and which you almost never see at an American McDo). I’ve eaten there on every single trip; and almost never at home over the past 10 years. It’s always amusing to me when Europeans complain about the “McDonaldsization of the culture … just like in America.” I always say something like, “Well, in America at least, McDonald’s is failing.”

  2. Emmanuelle Avatar

    Just realized Matt left the previous comment, but I wanted to say the same thing. The salads with white wine sauce, the crispy buns and the “peasant” fries in French McDonald’s restaurants are just really good. The coffee is excellent and they even have delicious chocolate brownies. You pay more, proportionally, for a menu: if I remember well, it’s the equivalent of one hour of work at the French minimum wage for a Big Mac menu. But the quality is remarkable. I never go to Mc Do in the U.S., only in Europe. Of course, customers there need to decide if they want to take the risk of eating the beef there.