: Thomas Burg announces Blogtalk II this July in Vienna.
Posts from November 5, 2003
The citizens’ media industry
: I’ll give you just this one fact from the Foursquare conference: I asked Jonathan Miller, the head of AOL, how much of his audience’s time is spent with audience-generated content.
He replied: 60-70 percent.
Think about that: Two-thirds of the time, the audience is looking at the audience’s own content, not the pro’s.
There’s an industry there, an industry that has barely been born.
Imagine if two-thirds of our time and channels on TV were spent looking at stuff created by fellow viewers. Or two-thirds of the books on Borders’ shelves. Or two-thirds of the pages of the newspaper. Or two-thirds of the magazines on the racks. Or two-thirds of the music on our shelves or Ipods.
Imagine if two-thirds — or one third or, hell, one percent — of the resources and advertising now devoted to media came to citizens’ media (which is what I’ll call audience content because the words “audience” and “content” are both loaded in some circles).
Citizens’ media is hugely powerful because citizens create it and citizens like it. But it is not getting the attention it deserves.
: As the panels gabbed on, I sat down and made notes on the elements of a citizens’ media industry. Not all of this can or should come from one company. Some will come from AOL, Microsoft, Yahoo, and known players; some will come from newcomers; some will come from you or me. But all of this is business waiting to be grabbed:
> Tools to create content. This means weblog tools and video and audio tools. It means mobile tools, too. And it means tools for individuals and groups.
> Tools to manage and share content. We need the means to store and serve our stuff, to file it away and find it again.
> The means to find the stuff we want to find: searches, directories, links, categorization, recommendations, reviews. If you can’t find the content, it’s not content yet.
> The means to find and make stars. All citizens’ media will not be created equal. Stars will emerge. Stars will move to other media. This will also validate citizens’ media. It’s a two-sided coin: The creators will need agents and marketers to discover them and package them and sell them; the audience of audiences will need help to find the best: It’s the atomic American Idol.
> The capture of buzz. The unique value of citizens’ media is that it captures what the citizens — the audience, the marketplace, the electorate, depending on your vantage — are thinking and saying. That needs to be grabbed and measured, a la Technorati.
> Interactivity. This is first and foremost a social enterprise. People want to talk and share. That is much of the content of the people’s content.
> Targeting. What will make all this pay, economically, is that all this allows marketers who are allowed in to target messages to willing and receptive audiences; that will be the key and killer strength of citizens’ media over the pro’s.
What you end up with is content the people create and the people care about. And the people aren’t just people; they are influencers, marketers (who better to convince you to buy a new cell phone than a user of that cell phone), critics, creators. We are people who matter.
There’s a business in this, a big business, and so far — apart from the odd toolmaker — nobody paying sufficient attention to it.
At the front
: Zeyad gives us another reality check on the mood and coverage he sees in Baghdad:
First, I have to explain to some western idealists that public demonstrations is an alien idea to the majority of Iraqis. We have been forced to demonstrate in favour of Saddam, the Ba’ath, Palestine, and Arab nationalism for 3 decades. Just to give you an idea on how that was like for us; party members would surround colleges, schools, and govt. offices. They block all outlets and shove people into buses which head to wherever the demonstrations are to be held. You simply cannot refuse to demonstrate. I remember hiding in the toilet back in high school whenever the buses came into the park to herd us to the demos. It wasn’t a pleasant experience I can tell you. Once I got stuck and had to shout anti-imperialist slogans at one of these rallies just two years ago. You don’t have the slightest idea of what it is like to live your life daily in fear.
Now today, we are facing terrorist and violent threats against our nurseries, schools, colleges, hospitals, clinics, oil pipelines, power stations, water purification systems, and other civilian facilities. If you think that a peaceful demonstration would deter those criminals from doing harm to us, then you are 100% wrong. Do you think the Syrians/Saudis/Iranians/Yemenis/Sudanese would simply say ‘Oh look, the Iraqis don’t want us there, lets go home and leave the Americans and Iraqis work it out’? Or if you think we should go out and face the dangers just to prove to you -paranoid Americans sitting in your ivory towers watching tv- that we do not support the terrorists, then you are wrong again.
You see a handful of teenagers dancing in front of the camera celebrating dead Americans, and you judge an entire people, you start whining about pulling the troops out of Iraq and giving the Iraqis what they deserve. Are you people really so close-minded? It is the fault of your news agencies that show you what they want, its certainly not ours….
Let me be honest. Look at what 9/11 did to you. It shocked you, and you can’t get over it to this day. Well let me invite you to Iraq where 9/11 is an everyday reality. How would you live your life? Stop comparing your ‘perfect’ society with mine. It isn’t the same. People don’t think the same. We don’t put flags and stickers on our cars to show how patriotic we are. We don’t go out in a ‘dentists against terrorism’ demonstration. We still don’t have your free-speech and other social niceties yet.
Another thing I’m sure you haven’t seen in your news. There are paintings on the walls all over Baghdad warning Arab foreigners from a bloody revenge if they keep messing with our affairs. Iraqis are openly calling the GC to quit the Arab League.
He ends angry that some people think he should be out demonstrating, people who don’t realize that his weblog is the most powerful demonstration one man in Baghdad can possibly give us.
At Foursquare again today… WBL (will blog later).